I received an ATA flight case of the type linked; note the exposed/protruding latches, and lack of lock (understandable I suppose if TSA wants to confirm I’m not a drug/baby smuggler.) My concern is how secure these latches will be, when subject to tossing/typical airline abuse; how easy do these fly open? Am I paranoid or correct in my assumption that these come open easier than ideal? What latch would be a better option?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Collapse
X
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
You are correct -I wouldn't buy an ATA flight case without butterfly latches or another higher rated latch honestly.
Those latches aren't good for anything other than supervised personal transport.“For me, when everything goes wrong – that’s when adventure starts.” Yvonne Chouinard
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
What kind of guitar is it for? For that price you can probably find a model specific case. Most of the new ones are molded plastic, but they have much nicer latches. I would trust them more than an low end Anvil-type case that may use really thin wood, FWIW, I have had a couple of those generic Anvil-style ones, the SKB and Gator ones are much nicer and hold your guitar much better. There is also a reason the guys like SKB and Gator are still around, they do know what they are doing.
Gator Cases produces a vast array of protective solutions and accessories, catering to everyone from budding musicians to seasoned studio and stage professionals.
SKB Cases is a manufacturer dedicated to travel, storage, and shipping protection needs for music, pro audio, sporting goods and industrial applications including government and military contract fulfillment.
I will default to NegativeEase's extensive touring knowledge over my own though.Last edited by devastone; 06-27-2019, 01:02 PM.
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Thanks - This was just a ‘bonus’ that a guitar was shipped in; ensconced my American Special Jazzmaster safely from FedEx across the country, but leery about it being transported outside a box itself.Originally posted by King BuzzoI love when people come up to me and say “Your guitar sound was better on Stoner Witch, when you used a Les Paul. “...I used a Fender Mustang reissue on that, dumbass!
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Originally posted by Silence Kid View PostThanks - This was just a ‘bonus’ that a guitar was shipped in; ensconced my American Special Jazzmaster safely from FedEx across the country, but leery about it being transported outside a box itself.
Since the case is made of ABA plastic and Aluminum trim, you could upgrade the latches to another system
Like these butterfly style that you trim and punch rivots in (pretty easy to do):
or the high end style of these are heavy duty rated
“For me, when everything goes wrong – that’s when adventure starts.” Yvonne Chouinard
Comment
-
ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
I have that brand of case for some rack equipment. The lid and latches fit so tight you’d have to hit it hard to flip the latches open.
When I toured with anvil type cases we used to just duct tape over the latches. Made it to Eastern Europe and around the continental US for 4 months with no problem whatsoever.
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
What the hell is a light duty ATA case? Having flown with multiple guitars at this point what ive always done is what beau did and just duct tape the latches."It keeps you fit - the alcohol, nasty women, sweat on stage, bad food - it's all very good for you." -Bon Scott
"Let me put it this way: the 5150 will treat
you better than any girlfriend, because it screams louder, it's easier to pick up, and it shuts up when you take your plug out." -Rip Glitter
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
And not only the type of latch, but there are only 2 of them. Not good. The duct tape suggestion is good, however, and may make this case ok as long as your guitar fits securely inside.
Personally, I would feel more comfortable with my guitar in a better case with better latches and more of them (at least three, but four would be better) to survive the flight experience.Originally Posted by IanBallard
Rule of thumb... the more pot you have, the better your tone.
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
DOH, sorry, read past the part where you already received the case. I guess you could try taping them, but these days they will probably pull it off, they are going to open it. IF they are tight, they will probably be fine, I worry more about that style getting damaged than coming open on their own, and as Doc said, I would prefer one or two more of them.
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Originally posted by NegativeEase View PostIf the case is nice, you could upgrade the latches.
Since the case is made of ABA plastic and Aluminum trim, you could upgrade the latches to another system
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Originally posted by beaubrummels View PostI have that brand of case for some rack equipment. The lid and latches fit so tight you’d have to hit it hard to flip the latches open.
When I toured with anvil type cases we used to just duct tape over the latches. Made it to Eastern Europe and around the continental US for 4 months with no problem whatsoever.
The problem is TSA and other international security will rip off that tape if it gets secondary inspection -and since guitars often have petroleum off gassing odors like Naptha and lubricants etc -they get inspected a lot internationally. If you put a pedal in the case it's even more likely. and If they replace the tape which is unlikely -it will be half a**ed -So it's a calculated risk -as if the tape is removed, when those latches get banged being handled, loaded, or on the transport vehicles of belt -they will pop open and a guitar could spill out
-I fly about 50-70 times year and see cases on the belts and in the heavy luggage section busted open -Granted I've only seen a guitar OUT of a case on the belt once in 3 decades.“For me, when everything goes wrong – that’s when adventure starts.” Yvonne Chouinard
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Thanks for the advise and suggestions - yeah I figured TSA would be likey to pop it open. I'm not a huge traveling musician or anything, but happen to have some guitars I need to get from NorCal to SoCal so my judgment is how safe the case would be for that purpose since I'm not up for boarding with a gig bag. I typically fly Southwest; they (by law) inform you at boarding if you have a gig bag, whether it must be sent down with the checked luggage - But you don't know till then, and if you're in the last boarding group it might not be allowed carry-on. I worry about things being crushed by some person's roller bag, even if I got that far.Originally posted by King BuzzoI love when people come up to me and say “Your guitar sound was better on Stoner Witch, when you used a Les Paul. “...I used a Fender Mustang reissue on that, dumbass!
Comment
-
Re: ATA Flight Case - Latch Concerns
Originally posted by Silence Kid View PostThanks for the advise and suggestions - yeah I figured TSA would be likey to pop it open. I'm not a huge traveling musician or anything, but happen to have some guitars I need to get from NorCal to SoCal so my judgment is how safe the case would be for that purpose since I'm not up for boarding with a gig bag. I typically fly Southwest; they (by law) inform you at boarding if you have a gig bag, whether it must be sent down with the checked luggage - But you don't know till then, and if you're in the last boarding group it might not be allowed carry-on. I worry about things being crushed by some person's roller bag, even if I got that far.
Here it is -everything you'd ever want to know about traveling with a guitar and why carrying on a ruggedized soft case is superior in most scenarios.
Last edited by NegativeEase; 06-28-2019, 10:39 AM.“For me, when everything goes wrong – that’s when adventure starts.” Yvonne Chouinard
Comment
Comment