Too gainy and a bit raspy. More "Fair Warning" than "VH I". Certainly a good stab at a Van Halen tone, though.
IMO VH1 is not an A2 mag
it's A8 or A5
Strat lead and rhythm tones sound pretty close to Destroyer bridge pup (A8) tone, just a tad brighter. I think he most likely used the same A8 mag in the strat (probably Destroyer's neck pickup)
SD 59 clip: http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_songInfo.cfm?bandID=894154&songID=9326706
The duncan CC will not get the 1st record tone. Try the 78,PG!,59 or demonBottoms up and light up the sky are on van halen II,Van halen 1(first album)is the most aggressive out of all the van halen recordings,i have a hard time believeing that on van halen 1 that its just a stock cranked plexi with a variac,its to edgey and aggrssive to be just a stock plexi,i have owned many stock plexis from the late 60s and none sounded like that,what he have to keep in mind is that ED is a BSer when it comes down to his equipment.