Is there a problem with this diagram?

[Jack_TriPpEr]

I took another look and yes, both methods would work. The second methode keeps the phase the same with both HB on and the first method reverses it?

No, phase remains normal in both methods.

If you would like to discuss further, please start a new thread. This particular thread is meant to be dedicated to just SD diagrams that have confirmed issues that need to be corrected eventually.

[WDeeGee]

I took another look and yes, both methods would work. The second methode keeps the phase the same with both HB on and the first method reverses it?

[ArtieToo]

And just to clarify, Jack is correct. There's more than one way to "skin a kat", so to speak. Ultimately, what needs to be understood, is that if you want to "kill" the stud coil, you short out black and white. And if you want to "kill" the screw coil, you short out red and green. It doesn't matter, electrically, how you accomplish that. (Talking Seymour Duncan pups here. Others may be different.)

[Jack_TriPpEr]

Coil split to activate the adjustable screw coil. Wiring is incorrect, not sure what the correct way is, but this is not it.
Top drawing is correct, bottom is wrong.

WDeeGee,

Both are valid methods, just different ways of going about the task. I have used each one successfully in different projects previously. Sometimes because of limitations imposed by the other design elements of the circuit you're working on, you're not able to route the Series Link Pair to Hot like in Method 2 BUT your circuit allows you to route it to Ground, so you employ Method 1 to achieve the end result.

Please see the attached summary "slide" I created in quick-and-dirty fashion, for the 2 methods and the short explanation of each I added to the left. Maybe those explanations will clear something up for you.

Why do you believe Method 1 is incorrect? Did you try it and it not worked? If yes, please start a separate thread and I would be glad to help you troubleshoot it.

[WDeeGee]

This is the correct way to wire the coil split to activate the screw coil.

[WDeeGee]

Coil split to activate the adjustable screw coil. Wiring is incorrect, not sure what the correct way is, but this is not it.
Top drawing is correct, bottom is wrong.

[Jack_TriPpEr]

Thank you so much for adding that info to this thread.

No problem. Anything I can do to support a worthwhile thread.

[Mincer]

Thank you so much for adding that info to this thread.

[Jack_TriPpEr]

Can you explain what is wrong for others visiting this thread?

BeauBrummels is correct, no sound would be produced in either of those.

I added a Red wire that would replace the current, errant Black wire that comes off the volume pot and goes to the 5 way switch.

[Mincer]

There appears to be a number of drawings on the site like these two:

https://www.seymourduncan.com/images...H_5W_1V_1T.jpg
https://www.seymourduncan.com/images...H_5W_1V_1T.jpg

When I look at them, I would expect them to never produce sound.

Can you explain what is wrong for others visiting this thread?

[beaubrummels]

There appears to be a number of drawings on the site like these two:

https://www.seymourduncan.com/images...H_5W_1V_1T.jpg
https://www.seymourduncan.com/images...H_5W_1V_1T.jpg

When I look at them, I would expect them to never produce sound.

[ArtieToo]

We may be talking semantics. To me, "independent" is necessary for "blend." When I think of blending, I think of having one volume up, and one down. Then you can slowly bring one up to just the desired amount. You need independent to that.

But I can also see your point that if both are "up", you can bring one down just a bit, before it starts to kill the other pup. So, I guess there is some crossover here.

Edit: I just reread your post. You definitely stated that turning either down will kill both. My bad.

[AlexR]

50's wiring is not a blend. You're talking independent wiring.
And you can blend the pickups, just only to a certain degree as I mentioned in my post.

[ArtieToo]

Both.
The middle position does indeed allow for a blend....in fact this is exactly the same wiring diagram as found in a Les Paul (save for the fact they have tone controls too). And just like a Les Paul if you drop the volume of 1 pickup all the way down you shut off the whole sound in the middle position.

Hey Alex. That's not quite correct. If the 3-way is in the middle, either volume will kill both pups. The output jack will be shorted to ground through the pot. To get the "blend" affect, (aka 50's wiring), you need to reverse the connection from the left-most terminal to the center. In other words, pickup black wire to the center wiper, and the left-most terminal out to the 3-way switch.

[ArtieToo]

I assumed this wiring, with the switch in the middle position, would allow me to have a blend of each pickups volume, similar to a Les Paul.
Instead, in the middle position, each volume acts as a master for both pickups.

No blend. Master volume is correct. Read on in my next post.