Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

    First off, thanks to everyone who contributed to the poll. As I've mentioned before, it's no easy task trying to come up with five favorite guitarists, let alone rank them. Still, I think it was a fun challenge for everyone involved.

    Secondly, let me say I hope you all don't hate me for pulling a fast one on you with the phony Top 20 list. I need to have a little fun on April Fools' Day. You were good sports about it, and even given that fake list, a lot of people came up with strong arguments for why so-and-so should or should not have made the list. At a minimum, it was an interesting sociological experiment. (I will admit that a small handful of members were in on the gag, but I will not reveal their names.)

    Lastly, I'd like to remind everyone that this is a culmination of votes for favorite guitarists, not best guitarists. It's a representation of the opinions and tastes of a small sample of forum members. (I received ranked votes from 194 forum members, with a total of 290 unique guitarists counted.) I did my best to include as many people as possible in a short amount of time.

    What follows is a list of the top 75 guitarists, as favored by the SDUGF. I could list more, but as you get further down the list, you get a lot of three-, four- and five-way ties. (There are, in fact, 77 guitarists represented in the list, but the last three -- #75, #76 and #77 -- were actually in a tie, so I had to include all three.)

    Again, this is the real list -- no Willie Nelson here. Take time to read through it, find where your picks landed, then have a fun discussion about the results. Thank you, everyone!

    - Keith
    Last edited by Pink Unicorn Horsey; 04-02-2008, 09:04 PM. Reason: Added Seven Missing Vote Counts
    Originally posted by ImmortalSix
    I am just jug the merlot

  • #2
    Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

    well....good thing you posted it

    edit: the ultimate april fool's joke!!!
    Originally posted by kilphody
    There is no such thing as useless knowledge.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

      YOU BAR-STEWARD!!!!! Ha ha ha nice one, I had my suspicions but has you obviously put ALOT of effort into it I didn't want to offend. Great gag and cool idea for a poll! Glad your back... you F*$£er you.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

        LOL!! I knew it!


        PUNK!!!
        I get weak in the knees at the sight of a vintage Fender amp!

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

          The guitarists are ranked using a weighted scoring system. A guitarist voted #1 in your list received five points, #2 received four points, and so on. The Ct. column represents how many votes the guitarist received, and the Wt. column represents the weighted ranking. Just for fun, I put the Rolling Stone ranking from their "100 Greatest Guitarists of All Time" article at the end, under the RS column. (We all have our opinions about that article, so it should make for some good banter.)

          For ties, where the Wt. and Ct. scores matched, I used how many #1 votes the guitarists received as tie-breakers. If it still was a tie, I used the number of #2 votes, and so on. As you can see from the list, there still are a few ties. That's OK in my book.

          The list follows in the next post.

          - Keith
          Originally posted by ImmortalSix
          I am just jug the merlot

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

            Code:
            Rank    Name                      Ct.    Wt.    RS
            1       Jimi Hendrix               58    206     1
            2       Jimmy Page                 46    156     9
            3       Edward Van Halen           39    131    70
            4       David Gilmour              38    125    82
            5       Stevie Ray Vaughan         38    121     7
            6       Eric Clapton               34    106     4
            7       Jeff Beck                  28    98     14
            8       Tony Iommi                 14    56     86
            9       Slash                      21    51      -
            10      Ritchie Blackmore          14    49     55
            11      Steve Vai                  17    43      -
            12      Joe Satriani               15    37      -
            13      Billy Gibbons              11    34      -
            14      Duane Allman               10    34      2
            15      "Dimebag" Darrell Abbott   10    31      -
            16      Jerry Cantrell             12    29      -
            17      Paul Gilbert               10    29      -
            18      Brian May                  10    29     39
            19      Carlos Santana              9    29     15
            20      John Frusciante             7    27     18
            21      Mark Knopfler               9    26     27
            22      Adam Jones                  6    26     75
            23      Angus Young                11    25     96
            24      Warren Haynes               9    24     23
            25      Eric Johnson                8    24      -
            26      George Harrison             8    24     21
            27      Pete Townshend              7    24     50
            28      Ace Frehley                 5    24      -
            29      Gary Moore                  8    23      -
            30      Adrian Smith/Dave Murray    6    23      -
            31      Alex Lifeson                7    21      -
            31      Randy Rhoads                7    21     85
            33      George Lynch                6    21      -
            34      Shawn Lane                  5    20      -
            35      James Hetfield              7    19      -
            36      Kim Thayil                  6    19    100
            37      Robin Trower                5    19      -
            38      Michael Schenker            5    17      -
            39      Pat Metheny                 5    16      -
            40      Trey Anastasio              4    15     73
            41      B.B. King                   5    14      3
            42      Tom Morello                 5    14     26
            43      Derek Trucks                4    14     81
            44      Brian Setzer                3    14      -
            45      Al DiMeola                  5    13      -
            46      John Petrucci               4    13      -
            47      Guthrie Govan               3    13      -
            47      Mike Campbell               3    13      -
            49      Buckethead                  6    12      -
            50      Joe Perry                   5    12     48
            51      Mikael Åkerfeldt            5    12      -
            51      Rory Gallagher              5    12      -
            53      Nuno Bettencourt            4    12      -
            54      Peter Green                 3    12     38
            55      John McLaughlin             3    11     49
            56      Mike McCready               3    11      -
            57      Ty Tabor                    3    11      -
            58      Buddy Guy                   6    10     30
            59      Yngwie J. Malmsteen         5    10      -
            60      Paul Kossoff                4    10     51
            60      Zakk Wylde                  4    10      -
            62      Richie Sambora              4    10      -
            63      Alex Skolnick               3    10      -
            64      Dave Mustaine               3    10      -
            65      Josh Homme                  4     9      -
            66      Allan Holdsworth            4     9      -
            67      Jake E. Lee                 3     9      -
            68      Jason Becker                3     9      -
            68      Leslie West                 3     9      -
            68      Steve Morse                 3     9      -
            71      Dann Huff                   2     9      -
            71      Pepper Keenan               2     9      -
            73      John Sykes                  2     8      -
            73      Marty Friedman              2     8      -
            75      Dean DeLeo                  2     8      -
            75      Rik Emmett                  2     8      -
            75      Warren DeMartini            2     8      -
            Last edited by Pink Unicorn Horsey; 04-02-2008, 08:41 PM. Reason: Added Seven Missing Vote Counts
            Originally posted by ImmortalSix
            I am just jug the merlot

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

              The top 7 are no suprise, but Tony Iommi at #8 ????
              I don't get that one.
              My Soundclick page

              ʎʌɐǝɥ sı ǝʇsɐd ɥsıɟ

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                ****, i was had in the other thread.

                3 of my top 5 are in the top 75 (52, 32 & 64 respectively).

                With Hendix & Page as 1 & 2 it shows how many old bastards we have on the board. Lol.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                  Hmmm . . . not a single one of my choices made the list . . .
                  Join me in the fight against muscular atrophy!

                  Originally posted by Douglas Adams
                  This planet has - or rather had - a problem, which was this: most of the people living on it were unhappy for pretty much of the time. Many solutions were suggested for this problem, but most of these were largely concerned with the movements of small green pieces of paper, which is odd because on the whole it wasn't the small green pieces of paper that were unhappy.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                    What were your choices?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                      Great list, great work, thanks man.

                      One of my dudes didn't make the top 75! Where's Brent Hinds?
                      I'm happy to see the rest of my favorites up there, though. My list follows:

                      1. Mike Campbell
                      2. Kim Thayil
                      3. Alex Lifeson
                      4. Mikael Åkerfeldt
                      5. Brent Hinds

                      It could probably still change by day with an exception or two.. Jerry Cantrell almost edged Thayil, but I had to give Kim the nod for the more innovative work. I guess I've been feeling pretty proggy lately!
                      Last edited by sosomething; 04-01-2008, 01:30 PM.
                      -Adam

                      Hear or Follow my music:

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                        BTW, if you want the full list, PM me and I can email it to you. (I have it in an Excel spreadsheet.

                        For the sake of privacy, I will remove the individual forum members' names from the matrix I used.

                        - Keith
                        Originally posted by ImmortalSix
                        I am just jug the merlot

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                          I'm kinda surprised that all of the guitarists I voted for are in the top 25, especially Adam Jones and Jerry Cantrell. I'm also surprised both of those guys are ahead of Dime on this list, who was my #1, and I thought he'd be higher on most people's lists. Great poll, though. Thanks for taking the time to do this, man. I'm sure everyone who participated appreciates it.

                          My list was:

                          1) Dime (He was the one who inspired me to pick up the guitar, so he has to be #1)
                          2) Adam Jones
                          3) Jerry Cantrell
                          4) Paul Gilbert
                          5) Jimi Hendrix (Though, I wish I would've put David Gilmour here instead, but I'd totally forgotten about him... )
                          Last edited by sufferinrewind; 04-01-2008, 01:29 PM.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                            I can't beleive it... Buckethead scored higher than Dave Mustaine?!?

                            Cool prank bud...
                            If I know I'm going crazy, I must not be insane.

                            Originally posted by TheLivingDead
                            DON'TGETMADBRO

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: The REAL List: SDUGF's Favorite Guitarists

                              4/5 for me, and I just missed with Claption.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X