A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

[DreX]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

Too bad he's gone now, but I wanted to post some real numbers for our science discussion that the rest of all you believers are not going to believe. I reread the entire thread from the beginning to put this together.

• 34 members posted
  
• ~25 directly contributed ideas or method proposals for running a valid, controlled scientific experiment
  
• Only 4 within the thread ever stated a belief that wood affected tone
  
• 2 of those 4 believed the affect would not be consistent enough, or able to be isolated enough, to generalize or predict the affect by species
  
• None of those 4 who believed wood affected tone were ever labeled as 'tonewood believers' or attacked as being part of the other 'side'
  
• About 9 pages of the first 14 were attacks on people who were actually contributing in support of the topic
  
• This list was electromechanically reproduced. So what of it?

Have a good day.

So nobody really disagreed with Tonewoods, and all that back there was a harmonious exchange of thoughts and ideas. I must have just taken it all wrong.

[beaubrummels]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

So nobody really disagreed with Tonewoods, and all that back there was a harmonious exchange of thoughts and ideas. I must have just taken it all wrong.

It was an exchange. Calling it harmonious would not be scientific.

[AlexR]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

^^ Sometimes people just don't want to deal with it. I am of the belief wood is an important (but minor) part of tone, but couldn't be bothered posting as it degraded very fast.

[Myaccount876]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

I think a non-spambot member being banned within a week of joining is a new record.

[LesStrat]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

He did not. At the time I scienced, all 44 of his posts were in this thread. The count has wavered due to various post deletions.

He wood have had more, but the mods took a router and carved out the other tonewoods thread.

[hydro]

Re: A few specific questions about testing wood influence on tone

huhuhuh