All's well that ends well (A 59 set story)

misterwhizzy

Well-known member
I've had a love/hate relationship with this 59 set I've had for years and years since the day I bought them. I think the problem ended up being the Les Paul I kept trying to put it in. They just don't like each other. On a related note, I still can't get this oil to mix with my water.

I've also had a bit of a love/hate relationship with my PRS SE Custom 22. It sounds amazing unplugged, but most pickups ended up just sending a nasally all-mids tone to the amplifier. I had solved this somewhat by using a set of Phat Cats, but I never really gelled that much with them either. I decided to give the 59s a shot just because. And that's where the fun began.

I got the Phat Cats out and the 59s in and soldered, but when I went to adjust the pickup height on the bridge, I heard a twang and realized the long legs on the 59B baseplate weren't going to work. I had unscrewed it all the way Fortunately, I had an extra baseplate from Philadelphia Luthier Supply that came when I swapped the baseplate on my Demon that went in a Superstrat recently. In the process of pulling the braid away from the baseplate while desoldering it, I also pulled it separate from the pickup lead wire. So I had to resolder that wire and solder the braid to the new baseplate as well as the grounding wire. Then I had to heat up the wax holding the maple spacer in place and remove it and transfer that over as well. I basically rebuilt the entire pickup. Before I mounted it in the pickup ring, I took a quick reading and got 8.5k. Thank God.

Anyway, this guitar loves it. It's got plenty of heft, a nice PAF sound without being weak, and my only gripe is it's just a little too bright even with the tone rolled back halfway, but that's nothing swapping the tone cap shouldn't fix. The neck sounds great without needing a different magnet, although it may still have the roughcast A3 in there I put in it years ago when I was still giving it a chance in the neck of my LP. I don't really understand why short legs aren't standard, but enough with my complaining. This might have saved a guitar.
 
That's a cascade of worst case scenarios when swapping pickups! But happy in the end, the scooped 59s worked well in a mid-heavy guitar.
 
Yeah my LP classic is similar. even with the '59s it's not lacking in mids,
i had no trouble with the long legs of course
 
glad you found a good home for the 59 set!

short legs are standard on lots of pups but all duncan paf models have long legs like the old ones. and if youre putting them in a lp, then they work fine. you can always order them with short legs or swap the baseplate, as you did, but its a bit of a pita
 
I changed the baseplates to short legs on all of my Duncans that came otherwise. You really do need those long legs on some hollow body archtop guitars though.
 
Swapping the baseplate seems so simple until you realize the ground wire and the braid are both soldered to it, and the spacer needs to be moved over as well, all while holding the coils and the magnet together.
 
yeah, its not terrible, but its a pita for sure. if youre buying new, just get what ya need. if you buy used, as i usually do, then swap if ya need to
 
Back
Top