Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

dr.barlo

New member
Such a vast and valuable information over there. I cannot believe that I missed it until recently. For the last month or so I am reading through all the the questions and answers, and believe me they are great.

http://www.seymourduncan.com/website/support/seymours_q_and_a.shtml

Here is one question and answer that I think would interest everybody here:

Q: 155. What makes the different pickup models sound different even thought they look alike? Jeff Andrews - London, England

A: Pickups can many factors that make them sound different even though they may look identical. There are many variables and some are listed below:
1. The number of turns on each bobbin
a. The number to turns per layer (pitch)
b. The number of layers per total turns
c. Tension in grams when winding
d. The winding speed of the bobbin
e. The de-reeling of the magnet wire from the master spool
f. The lubricant and seating of the magnet wire per-layer
g. Traverse and winding area
h. Precision pitch control for desired gauge of magnet wire
2. The gauge of magnet wire (Bare Wire)
a. Minimal diameter, Nominal diameter & Maximum diameter (bare dimensions)
b. Nominal area in circular mils
c. Nominal ohms per 1000’ @ 20 C
d. Nominal ohms per pound @ 20 C
e. Pounds per 1000’
f. Feet per pound
3. The insulation thickness on a particular gauge of magnet wire
a. Increase in film or insulation diameter
b. Minimal, Nominal & Maximum
4. The bobbin shape
a. The bobbin length
b. The bobbin width
c. The bobbin height
d. The bobbin material
e. More specific bobbin dimensions
5. The pole piece shape and material
a. Steel rod slugs
b. metal bar or blade (shape and size)
c. Fingers (single or multiple)
d. Magnet rod pole piece (various material and strength)
e. Screw pole piece (various threads, length, diameter and head shape)
f. Iron core material with shapes
g. Magnet bars of various shapes (various material and strength)
6. Magnet Material
a. Alnico’s (2,3,4,5,7)
b. Ceramics (various grades)
c. Cobalt steels
d. Rare earth magnets
e. electromagnets (DC with various power supplies)
f. Barium Ferrite rubber bonded magnets
g. Strength or weakness of magnet
h. fully magnetized, de-gaussed or calibrated
7. Electrical Phasing
a. Series In phase
b. Series out of phase
c. Parallel in phase
d. Parallel out of phase
e. Split adjustable
f. Split non-adjustable
g. In phase with accompanying pickup
h. Out of phase with accompanying pickup
8. Magnetic Phasing
a. In phase
b. Out of phase
c. In phase with accompanying pickup
d. Out of phase with accompanying pickup
9. The guitar string gauge
a. String gauge
b. String alloy
c. String age and use
d. String spacing from pole to pole
e. String height from pickup
f. Neck scale and string length
g. String pitch and tuning
10. Other factors that make a pickup sound different
a. Body and neck material
b. Body and neck weight
c. Electrical circuit (switches, volume and tone controls values)
d. Guitar cord
e. Effects being used
f. Fret height and width
g. Tail piece
h. Vibrato or Tremolo’s
i. Pickup covers- material, thickness & plating
j. Gauge of hookup wire-solid or stranded and number of strands
k. Pickup mounting-mounting ring, pickguard, mounted into body
l. Pickup placement-distance from bridge and neck
m. Angle of pickup-angled or perpendicular
n. Amplification being used
o. Speaker combination
p. Your individual ears- depending on the time, loudness and frequency will make your pickup sound different
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Yeah, I've seen it, very good, still haven't fineshed reading 'em all though
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Dr. Barlo,

I have read almot the entire thing...in fact I read several parts last night doing research for the Barlobuckers! I found out how to tell Seymour or MJ exzactly what they need to be constructed like! But I will say this...that is one of the most intense pickup writings I have ever seen!!!
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

the guy who invented said:
Dr. Barlo,

I have read almot the entire thing...in fact I read several parts last night doing research for the Barlobuckers! I found out how to tell Seymour or MJ exzactly what they need to be constructed like! But I will say this...that is one of the most intense pickup writings I have ever seen!!!

Vow thanks man. I am also going over them because of that, to learn more about the details. 'Cause it's fun!

It is definitely the most intense writing about pickups I have ever seen. It even has the very detailed table about the magnetic properties of various alnico grade magnet bars. I remember asking tonsa folk, and finally a small pickup winder (he is a gentleman) answering. But then again the list over in the q-a is much more detailed.

Why didn't you guys tell me of that q-a section before? :banghead:

B :burnout:
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

dr.barlo said:
Vow thanks man. I am also going over them because of that, to learn more about the details. 'Cause it's fun!

It is definitely the most intense writing about pickups I have ever seen. It even has the very detailed table about the magnetic properties of various alnico grade magnet bars. I remember asking tonsa folk, and finally a small pickup winder (he is a gentleman) answering. But then again the list over in the q-a is much more detailed.

Why didn't you guys tell me of that q-a section before? :banghead:

B :burnout:

To be honest...I thought most people had read or seen it...I heve been allover this site, reading and learning...when you mentioned the Barlo Buckers that's the first place I went!

Sorry, I should have told you about it then!!! :smack:
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

I've read every word, and I reference it all the time. ;)

Its great that Seymour, et al., share this info with the world.

Artie
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

dr.barlo said:
Why didn't you guys tell me of that q-a section before?
Doc,
I agree, it's great reading for anyone interested in pickups.

that section was added a few months ago. Evan posted at the time, and said they would be adding to it over time.
between that section and the FAQ, there's quite a bit of info on pickups specifically, and guitar playing in general
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Believe it or not, we're still not done adding to this section. I'm glad you're finding it useful.

These were his Vintage Guitar Magazine articles before they were sent to the editor. So please excuse any typos.
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Evan Skopp said:
Believe it or not, we're still not done adding to this section. I'm glad you're finding it useful.

These were his Vintage Guitar Magazine articles before they were sent to the editor. So please excuse any typos.

Evan,

Has Seymour taken a hiatus from writing for VG? I'm sure he's plenty busy, but I used to love that section.

Jeff
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

The FAQ section is extremely useful too - especially for a newbie like me!
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Thats crazy, so much info, i gotta get reading!
 
Re: Are you guys aware of Seymour's Q and A section?

Curly said:
Doc,
I agree, it's great reading for anyone interested in pickups.

that section was added a few months ago. Evan posted at the time, and said they would be adding to it over time.
between that section and the FAQ, there's quite a bit of info on pickups specifically, and guitar playing in general

That explains it.

Keep up the great work Evan, really I find it very useful.

B
 
Back
Top