Best floor modeller under $500?

Reload in 5

Just Ultimate Slacker
I know, this has been asked before, but stick with me.
I play acoustic on Sunday mornings worship, and electric for Wednesday night youth worship. On Wednesdays I use a Jet City with my timmy copy and memory boy. Not much use for clean there, someone else plays acoustic so a kinda clean sound is all I need.
I have filled in on Sunday mornings playing electric. We use PODs for guitar and bass. I always used 4 sounds, a clean tone, a slightly overdriven tone, a heavier tone, and a lead tone. All based on Marshall amps (I think the clean was a fender though)

So I just found out Sunday night is the last for the electric guitarist. i will start playing electric full time. He will take his POD HD500 with him. I have never used that, just the POD XT he had before that.

So, if you were in my position, what would you do?
USING AN AMP IS NOT AN OPTION. Gotta go direct with something. I would prefer something in the price range of the HD300, but dont want to limit possibilities in the future, so will go with an HD500 more than likely if I go Line 6.
What is better out there in the same price range? (under $500)
I used to have a sansamp gt2. If I had that I would at least give it a shot with my other pedals, but i Haven't seen it in years. I tried to find it at the house the other day but no luck. The once or twice I used it I remember the sound being very good, but never tried it with a drive in front. I could try to get a sansamp triAC to give me 3 sounds, then use the memory boy for delay on my lead sound. Put my wah in front if the urge strikes me (but it hardly ever does) and use my VP Jr volume at the end as an overall volume control. Could also put the timmy copy out front for lead boost if needed. I would put my Strobostomp in there for tuning (plus it has buzz feiten so thats a plus)

So what could you / would you do for under $500?
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Line 6 HDx would probably be the best bet. I use an RP1000 and have decent results with it, at the end of the day it's still digital.

If you already have pedals, maybe give the Blackstar HT-Dual pedal a try, it's basically the preamp section of the Venue series amps and it has a cab sim output. Just use it in place of an amp, if there are effects you normally use in the loop, just put those after the output.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Well, since you're not really saying the POD XT isn't cutting it, I'm not sure of what you're asking, unless he's taking it with him?
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

I was faced with a very similar dilemna just a few weeks ago:
https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?t=214336&highlight=Tonelab+ST

See Post #44 for what I finally had to do. It sounded a little better than OK, but not great.

The main thing is that I finally dialed in a tolerable clean tone in the Tonelab and then was able to externally select delays and OD using the pedals I am already accustomed to. The real drag is that an OD in front of a modeler will not yield the same satisfying results that you get when running it into a tube amp. I tried the Crunch Box and both sides of a KOT, but got the best results using the OCD.

To almost answer your question, I would suggest finding a used HD500 pronto or selling something to make up the difference between the 400 and 500. I was exactly like you ....... I could have swung the 400 financially, but I knew I'd ultimately want the flexibility of blending two chains that the HD-500 offers. Ultimately, I decided to do the best I could without buying anything except the Velcro required to assemble a board specifically for the "no stage volume" situation.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Re: Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Well, since you're not really saying the POD XT isn't cutting it, I'm not sure of what you're asking, unless he's taking it with him?

The XT left when he got the HD. It's all his stuff, including the bass POD (but its a really old model and he is leaving it)

Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Found an HD500 open box from AMS for $399
Line 6 only gives 90 day warranty, but AMS gives you a year.
Ordered it today. Will make its debut a week from this Sunday.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

The XT left when he got the HD. It's all his stuff, including the bass POD (but its a really old model and he is leaving it)

Ah, ok. I misunderstood. I thought you may have bought it from him when he bought the HD500, or maybe he donated it to the church.

Found an HD500 open box from AMS for $399
Line 6 only gives 90 day warranty, but AMS gives you a year.
Ordered it today. Will make its debut a week from this Sunday.

AMS usually has good deals on open-box stuff. I bought an Akai DPS12 from them years ago like that for about half what they were unopened. Looked like an in-store demo but had very little wear and actually outlasted the one I bought new/unopened.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

The Vox/Korg tonelabs are very good. I have one. Occasional useless effect in there but nothing that single pedals can't cure.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

Good deal @ $399 (I love AMS for used deals on stuff that barely qualifies as used, IMO). I'm still rocking my POD X3 Live, I've heard some people don't like the HD compared to it, but with updates it's looking sweeter and sweeter.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

I was faced with a very similar dilemna just a few weeks ago:
https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?t=214336&highlight=Tonelab+ST

See Post #44 for what I finally had to do. It sounded a little better than OK, but not great.

The main thing is that I finally dialed in a tolerable clean tone in the Tonelab and then was able to externally select delays and OD using the pedals I am already accustomed to. The real drag is that an OD in front of a modeler will not yield the same satisfying results that you get when running it into a tube amp. I tried the Crunch Box and both sides of a KOT, but got the best results using the OCD.

To almost answer your question, I would suggest finding a used HD500 pronto or selling something to make up the difference between the 400 and 500. I was exactly like you ....... I could have swung the 400 financially, but I knew I'd ultimately want the flexibility of blending two chains that the HD-500 offers. Ultimately, I decided to do the best I could without buying anything except the Velcro required to assemble a board specifically for the "no stage volume" situation.

Gotta agree on the HD models. Picked up a used 300 and it satisfied my curiosity about modellers but will sell know for 500 and it's increased switching ability
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

I have not yet test driven an HD500. I am satisfied with my X3L.

I'm not even sure what the diffs are.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

I have not yet test driven an HD500. I am satisfied with my X3L.

I'm not even sure what the diffs are.

HDs have looper on them, from the sounds clips that i have heard pretty much the only difference.

I have an X3L as well and I love it using live but I grew to hate the USB recording tones out of it. Always too fizzy and digital. It sounds great when you mic it up though.
 
Re: Best floor modeller under $500?

How is the 500 working out for you?
Great! I have 4 basic sounds dialed in, then I can also kick in pedals on each if wanted (Sunday morning had a Clean lead to play so added a comp and delay to my basic fender clean tone and it was nice)

Gotta agree on the HD models. Picked up a used 300 and it satisfied my curiosity about modellers but will sell know for 500 and it's increased switching ability

If you want to sell the 300 let me know. I want to get one for a Piano player that also occasionally plays guitar to use.
 
Back
Top