Boss ES-5

mantis

New member
Hello all,
Finally after decades of trying to figure out how to manage my rig, I finally got an ES-5. This is what I needed and never got.

Short Story.
I picked up a Boss GT-8 back when it came out. I was floored on what it could do amp control etc. Built on volume pedal and so many effects. Shorty after owning it and the excitement wore off, I noticed it changed my amps natural tone.
So after trying to get it right, I sold it and went back to pedals. Now I feel lost and have to manually control all these pedals and my amp.
I wrote this sone that required Delay, Chorus and Reverb for clean but then switched to the Drive channel with only Delay. Well that sucked to manage and click all those pedals.
Boss Released the GT-10 and talked about how improved it was over the GT-8 so I ran out and got one. Yes it was much better then the GT-8, it has an easier way of setting up and man I really liked it for a while. But it still altered my amps natural tone.
Went back to pedals
Boss released the GT-100 and talked about the nature sound and now it sounds better then anything they ever built etc etc etc. So what did I do? Ran out and got one.
This thing is even better then the GT-10 and it didn't alter my amps nature tone that much. It retained it much better then the 8 and 10. But now it adds some fuzzy tone to it and I had a terrible time trying to dial it out. I fought with it for a few years I'd say. Then it finally wore me out and I sold it and yet again went back to pedals.
Boss Released the MS-3 and I figured FINALLY this is it, this is the product I have been waiting for. I hybrid wired it into my system , I tried the 4 cable method with it as I've been using the 4 cable method since the GT-8 and my volume dropped out and my tone slightly changed, even less then the GT-100 but still did it.
Talked to Boss about it and they instructed me how to get around it. The delay not carrying over to other patches bothered me so I wired in my Flashback Delay outside the MS-3 and it just stayed on in my effects loop which I also removed from the MS-3 and had the Delay in there by it self.
I found myself putting Reverb and my Waza Chorus in the loop with it and started using the MS-3 less and less.
I had the 3 loops with my drive pedals and found I was basically using the MS-3 as a amp switcher. I didn't even use the internal Noise gate as I hybrid wired up my Sentry noise gate.
After thinking about it, I should have asked for a ES-5 or ES-8. Bam Billie steered me to a thread over at the gear forum and made the swap with a member for a ES-5.

The ES-5 is simply hands down amazing. IT DOES NOT alter my tone at all. You can plug directly into your amp or go through the ES-5 and I hear NO DIFFERENCE. I so love that. Boss built this thing almost perfectly.
The switching is lighting fast, there is no hard click when you do so, it just goes into the next patch effortlessly.
It's crazy easy to program and setup, I haven't even used the editor yet which I always have found incredibly useful but I was able to setup 5 patches in minutes as it's that easy from the front controls.

The Only thing I think Boss could have done with the ES-5 to make it better is to have the same Volume effects loop like the ES-8 does. Most people who use pedals probably put the Modulation effects in their effects loops as it just sounds so much better there. You have to lose a Loop to wire in the 4 cable method so you can place effects in front of your amp and ones in the effects loop.
I have to share 2 loops . Loop 1 I share a Spark Booster and a Dark Matter distortion pedal and have to manually turn on and off which one I want.
I also have to Share Loop 5 which has my Flashback Delay and Hall of Fame reverb, same thing manual control.

I probably Should consider down the road the ES-8 as it has 8 full loops plus the Volume loop so it really has 9 loops. But for now I'm tickled pink with the ES-5 and don't need to upgrade. I don't use a tone of effects so my board will probably not get any bigger then what it is now. One good thing about the Multi effects units is you get to try out 100's of effects and find the ones useful to you.
I just use OD Distortion , Chorus , Delay and reverb. I'm good with just them.
 
Boss ES-5

Congrats!

Pictures or it didn't happen :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Re: Boss ES-5

I can go back even further to the GT-10View attachment 82511

Ya know what, today(well yesterday now) evening after a long time, I was sitting with the gt10 trying to get some useable direct sounds. The cleans ended up sounding gorgeous with the tone modify-resonator 1 placed after the amp block(clean twin/tweed). Slightly dirty sounds were also acceptable(boss crunch/wildstack). Anything beyond & it sounded pathetic/artificial/digital. Even using a OD/Dist block in front of the clean amps wasn't helping.

That got me thinking, it's about time boss came out with a fx only unit, like the gsystem etc. Basically takeout the digital amp & od section and divert that horsepower towards the rest of the blocks, 'cause face it, the gt100 also wasn't a big improvement in the modelling section. Boss either needs a high end processor or new programmers, even zoom seems to be getting more love with their budget mfxs.

Anyways, glad the es5 works as it should with your rig this time. :bigok:
 
Re: Boss ES-5

Ya know what, today(well yesterday now) evening after a long time, I was sitting with the gt10 trying to get some useable direct sounds. The cleans ended up sounding gorgeous with the tone modify-resonator 1 placed after the amp block(clean twin/tweed). Slightly dirty sounds were also acceptable(boss crunch/wildstack). Anything beyond & it sounded pathetic/artificial/digital. Even using a OD/Dist block in front of the clean amps wasn't helping.

That got me thinking, it's about time boss came out with a fx only unit, like the gsystem etc. Basically takeout the digital amp & od section and divert that horsepower towards the rest of the blocks, 'cause face it, the gt100 also wasn't a big improvement in the modelling section. Boss either needs a high end processor or new programmers, even zoom seems to be getting more love with their budget mfxs.

Anyways, glad the es5 works as it should with your rig this time. :bigok:
Boss from the start up to the Current offerings SUCK at amp modeling. They sound nothing like the originals. I have owned many different amps and none of them in the GT's sound anything like them. Mesa isn't Mesa at all , not even close.

The Effects however they do a decent job.

They absolutely need to come out with a high end processor as they are slipping away in this area. I will never own another Boss Multi effects unit unless they come out with a High end model like Waza or better. I can't stand these things especially the 2 new Models.

The MS-3 is a step in the right direction but they should have poured higher end components into it and try to preserve tone better. The ES-5 does a wonderful job at that.
They should really consider using more analog internals and retaining them for as long as possible.
I also agree they need some new Programers. I want higher end from them or nothing at all.

Having pedals or having a multi effects unit I want them to sound the same or actually better with the Multi effects as you can eliminate the needs for patch cables and power supplies. Build a Multi effects unit with the Ultimate in clarity and reaction time. Make it so much more then the MS-3. The MS-s as I said is a great step in the right direction, now take off the limitations and go for broke.
 
Re: Boss ES-5

I was never impressed with Boss amp models. You are right, they are years behind what is currently out there. I have found, though, that if you are after new, creative sounds (that doesn't try to sound like a currentl
y available amp), you can come up with great stuff, even with old amp modeling. I used a Roland GP-100 for years. It still has good sounds, just don't compare the models to actual amps.
 
Re: Boss ES-5

I was never impressed with Boss amp models. You are right, they are years behind what is currently out there. I have found, though, that if you are after new, creative sounds (that doesn't try to sound like a currentl
y available amp), you can come up with great stuff, even with old amp modeling. I used a Roland GP-100 for years. It still has good sounds, just don't compare the models to actual amps.

Their algos sound like they borrowed them from some synth units & then tweaked a bit before putting them in their guitar processors. The models have sort of odd smoothness & clarity to their distortion that it sounds unusual when compared to real world units. While that can fit in a mix but for standalone practice & stuff, it gets tiring quickly.
 
Re: Boss ES-5

Many people seem really happy with their Boss Katana amps. I'm afraid it takes about 10 years to change the opinion of the average guitar player though. Maybe 20 years for the average forum guitar player.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Boss ES-5

Their algos sound like they borrowed them from some synth units & then tweaked a bit before putting them in their guitar processors. The models have sort of odd smoothness & clarity to their distortion that it sounds unusual when compared to real world units. While that can fit in a mix but for standalone practice & stuff, it gets tiring quickly.

Yes! That is exactly right. The Roland company makes some great stuff. The effects on their old units are still really great. I wonder why they lagged so far behind on modeling? I am sure the Katana sounds good in a room, but the demos I have heard still have a little ways to go to get to Helix/Fractal land.
 
Re: Boss ES-5

Yes! That is exactly right. The Roland company makes some great stuff. The effects on their old units are still really great. I wonder why they lagged so far behind on modeling? I am sure the Katana sounds good in a room, but the demos I have heard still have a little ways to go to get to Helix/Fractal land.
I think they keep trying to hit price points instead of building a higher quality unit. I'm willing to bet Boss could build the worlds best Modeling and effects Multi Processors if they felt they could sell them.
Think about this. The New MS-3 is $399. You get a 3 loop pedal switcher and 100+ effects amp control, Midi etc. All of that for only $399. Now think about if they doubled the quality and charged $699 for the same exact thing just high quality. Would it still sell? I would buy one if it sounded better was more analog and preserved your guitar and amps natural tone and added a dedicated loop for your amps effects loop. That to me would be well worth $699 even $799 would still be fine.
Think about now much it costs to build a nice pedal board. You can easily spend $2000.00 right? Thats pretty easy to do considering what a nice pedal switcher, cables , and all the effects your gonna want. Why not build a MS-3 like product of much higher quality? I know in my heart once people started using it and it can rival or even sound better then stand alone pedals, they would fly off the shelf.
The sheer weight of a fully loaded pedal board can get up there. Boss could build a MS-3 like product with no loops other then the loop for your amps effects loop and have all effects built in of the highest quality available and still sell a product like that for like lets say $999.99. Would you buy one IF it sounded as good as stand alone pedals or better? I sure would.
They could make the front of the switcher pure analog and send everything to the front of the amp in analog for drives OD type stuff even an analog buffer circuit. Then in the effects loop have the option to use analog or digital modulation effects. A built on Matrix switch for a built on volume and express pedals so you can move the volume pedal where you want it in pure analog form low impedance and the expression pedal to be matrix to any effect like OD level or Delay time.

If I worked for Boss I would propose this type of product and market it as the ULTIMATE PEDAL BOARD. I would make a carrying case for it and have it setup as a stage ready board with lights and a bigger more clear high quality screen. Have the case as optional but I'm sure most would use it as I would design it to make the most sense for use at home and on stage.

So who would seriously consider a product like this? What on the market would you say is the closest to something of this caliber?
 
Re: Boss ES-5

I will say, they have great ideas. I would hire a modern industrial designer, though. Roland/Boss products aren't 'pretty' and for a generation brought up on slick phones, and other tech, they are firmly stuck in what passed for modern in 1985.
 
Back
Top