It gets ya in the ballpark. In the right guitar (alder or ash strat body) it's right at home for doing EVH stuff. Heck, he used it himself on stuff, I think Fair Warning album and Panama are the CC and Judgement Day is for sure.
I've been playing for 20 years and have tried to get his tone for more than half of them. After a while (early on), I realized it's not going to happen. I'm not him, I don't have his fingers nor his talent. Plus I was playing the wrong gear...LOL. I had a 5150 but it still sounded like me. I have a Marshall and you guessed it, it still sounds like me. The closest I have gotten to the classic (VH1 and VHII) tone after all these years is the DiMarzio PAF in my homemade frankenstrat now combined with my Marshall. The CC is good for everything else.
So yeah, there's more than the pickup involved.