Re: hollowbodies
All the great Jazz players past and present play hollow body archtops. There are two specific types of hollow bodies, Laminated and solid woods. A Gibson 175 is a laminated body where a Gibson L5 is a solid wood guitar. A L5 is more of an acoustic guitar with floating pups that allow it to be amplified. The 175 has the pups mounted directly in the top. The pup holes iterupt the sound waves when it is played acoustic. So in a very strong sense the 175 is an electric guitar from the start. There are pros and cons to everything. The pros to a laminated arctop is they are much easier to control feedback, which is a constant problem performing with an archtop guitar. The Cons is they don't sound as good as a solid wood guitar does acousticly. A solid wood Archtop guitar in the hands of a real Jazz player is an amazing instrument. I have had the pleasure of playing many D'Angelicos and D'Aquistos. These guitars today sell for somwhere between 30K to 50K!!! When you hold a guitar like this in your hands you really begin to appriciate the artistry the craftsmen who built it used, and the artists who play them. So in response to your friends comments about an Archtop...... He has probably never really sat down and played a great archtop, and has certainly not listened to some of the worlds finest guitar players who play these instruments on a regular basis. People like Joe Pass, Kenny Burrell, Wes Montgomery just to name a few.