I dropped a Little 59 (strat bridge) into my Rogue lap steel replacing a chinese single coil that was there. Now I'm wondering if I should also change out the pots to 500k?
Welcome to the forum!
The Little 59 was desigend to drop right into a Strat with 250k pots, so if that is what you have, you will be fine. If you find that the tone is too dull, you can always increase the pot size later.