Need mixdown help

Re: Need mixdown help

I just wanna hear the finished product and read a detailed account of what you guys did to it:cool2:
Oh, just saw this post. :)

Hmm, okay:

1. First thing I did was listen to the original track and your rough premix. To tell you the truth, I prefer your arrangement to the original.


2. Took acoustic no. 1 and imported it into Cubase twice. Then I offset one of the tracks a few mS and panned them 90% left and right.

3. Took acoustic no. 2 and EQ'd it slightly different from acoustic no. 1 and panned it just left of center. I did the same with the intro guitar, so that when the vox start, they are the only thing panned to the center.

4. For reverb and compression, I used my UAD-1 card. I used a small wooden room for the acoustic tracks and ran a separate track for the 'verb. I then ran an insert from each acoustic track to the 'verb and adjusted the send level until it sounded right.

5. I did the same for the vocal track. This allowed the vox to be in the same sonic space as the guitars. I then added another vocal reverb with a subtle slap-back to the vocal track to give it some depth. I offset the predelay on the vocal reverb by 20mS.

6. EQ was pretty minimal. I added a small HF shelf to the acoustic guitars to give them some chime, and high passed all of the tracks (acoustic guitars around 100Hz, vox around 150Hz, bass at 50Hz). I added a bit of body to the vocals at 300Hz. Bass guitar had two boosts (at around 5k and 9k) and a cut at 2k to allow the vox to sit in the middle.

7. I primarily used a UA 1176SE compressor for the vocals, acoustic guitars, and bass. The bass was not compressed much to keep the attack and transparency high.

8. Vocal rides. LOTS of vocal rides. This evened out the vocal performance BEFORE I applied compression, which I used to smooth out the tone, not to dictate big level shifts.

9. There is a major vocal clunker at 3.40 on the original track. I copy/pasted an earlier pass at the same line and inserted it here to make the ending stronger.

10. I strapped a limiter across the stereo output and watched the levels overall.

11. Then I took the mixdown and added some corrective EQ, primarily at 10k to add some shimmer and attack to the guitars. I strapped another 1176SE across the mix to get the level hot and applied a minimalist limiter.

12. Finally, I inserted an Apogee UV22 across the stereo output and tried all of the dithering filters. Filter 2 gave me the most open and dynamic sound and added a couple dB of headroom to the mix.

I think that's everything.
 
Re: Need mixdown help

I quite like the song, not my usual sort of thing but pretty cool :)

I like how Binnerscott and TO have taken the mix in different directions :)
 
Re: Need mixdown help

I quite like the song, not my usual sort of thing but pretty cool :)

I like how Binnerscott and TO have taken the mix in different directions :)

They aren't really different directions as much as different techniques.

My mix is a little different in that the vox sit on top and the guitars are held back, kind of a pop mix more than anything - sitting there waiting for drums before they find there final levels. The bass is compressed to bring out more attack, which will sound much better with the drums in the picture than naked.

I got one stereo guitar track and one mono, so without knowing Hunter's intentions, I ran the stereo track L/R and the mono down the middle. I tried hard left and right with the two tracks, but some spots were just a little too rough for that.

TO, I like your use of a duplicate guitar track for space...nice jangle to it. I usually don't offset with a short delay. The natural chorus is great, but is also gives the impression of a small space.

I6 has to get us drums for this....
 
Re: Need mixdown help

Oh, just saw this post. :)

Hmm, okay:

1. First thing I did was listen to the original track and your rough premix. To tell you the truth, I prefer your arrangement to the original.


2. Took acoustic no. 1 and imported it into Cubase twice. Then I offset one of the tracks a few mS and panned them 90% left and right.

3. Took acoustic no. 2 and EQ'd it slightly different from acoustic no. 1 and panned it just left of center. I did the same with the intro guitar, so that when the vox start, they are the only thing panned to the center.

4. For reverb and compression, I used my UAD-1 card. I used a small wooden room for the acoustic tracks and ran a separate track for the 'verb. I then ran an insert from each acoustic track to the 'verb and adjusted the send level until it sounded right.

5. I did the same for the vocal track. This allowed the vox to be in the same sonic space as the guitars. I then added another vocal reverb with a subtle slap-back to the vocal track to give it some depth. I offset the predelay on the vocal reverb by 20mS.

6. EQ was pretty minimal. I added a small HF shelf to the acoustic guitars to give them some chime, and high passed all of the tracks (acoustic guitars around 100Hz, vox around 150Hz, bass at 50Hz). I added a bit of body to the vocals at 300Hz. Bass guitar had two boosts (at around 5k and 9k) and a cut at 2k to allow the vox to sit in the middle.

7. I primarily used a UA 1176SE compressor for the vocals, acoustic guitars, and bass. The bass was not compressed much to keep the attack and transparency high.

8. Vocal rides. LOTS of vocal rides. This evened out the vocal performance BEFORE I applied compression, which I used to smooth out the tone, not to dictate big level shifts.

9. There is a major vocal clunker at 3.40 on the original track. I copy/pasted an earlier pass at the same line and inserted it here to make the ending stronger.

10. I strapped a limiter across the stereo output and watched the levels overall.

11. Then I took the mixdown and added some corrective EQ, primarily at 10k to add some shimmer and attack to the guitars. I strapped another 1176SE across the mix to get the level hot and applied a minimalist limiter.

12. Finally, I inserted an Apogee UV22 across the stereo output and tried all of the dithering filters. Filter 2 gave me the most open and dynamic sound and added a couple dB of headroom to the mix.

I think that's everything.

Where did you learn all of that? Just experience? I don't even know what half of that means lol.
 
Re: Need mixdown help

They aren't really different directions as much as different techniques.

My mix is a little different in that the vox sit on top and the guitars are held back, kind of a pop mix more than anything - sitting there waiting for drums before they find there final levels. The bass is compressed to bring out more attack, which will sound much better with the drums in the picture than naked.

I got one stereo guitar track and one mono, so without knowing Hunter's intentions, I ran the stereo track L/R and the mono down the middle. I tried hard left and right with the two tracks, but some spots were just a little too rough for that.

TO, I like your use of a duplicate guitar track for space...nice jangle to it. I usually don't offset with a short delay. The natural chorus is great, but is also gives the impression of a small space.

I6 has to get us drums for this....

Maybe different 'directions' wasn't the best way to word what I meant, but I know what I meant to say :banghead:

I've done studio mixing/mastering in the past and could hear how you'd both approached it in different ways, I just hadn't thought about it in as much detail as yourself or TO had yet :D
 
Last edited:
Re: Need mixdown help

First off, huge thanks to both of the remixers!

Second off, the intro on both remixes is out of time alignment - probably because of a timing idiosyncrasy that happened in my recordings (I shifted every track except the intro to "the right" (read: a second or two later)). Would it be possible for you both to do the same (either move the guitar intro earlier, or move everything except the guitar intro later?

At the end of the intro, the single note walk-up, "G-A-B-C-D," the vocal and rhythm guitar should start after that D rings out for 2 beats or so. Do you know what I mean? It's apparent when you listen to the original Zac Brown Band song. Also, in my original mix. You can hear what I mean there.

I love both mixes, they are both so different, and both have such wonderful qualities.

I am sending them to Kyle (the singer) today to see what he thinks. We're doing this for his family.

Binnerscot - could you enable download for your remix, so I can send it over to Kyle?

Thank you, thank you, thank you guys!!!

-Hunter
 
Re: Need mixdown help

Nice versions on both. I can see (hear) how Binnerscott's begs for drums, however, TO's sounds more as if it [the song] was made to be without drums.
 
Re: Need mixdown help

So... Do we want drums?

I could do with some drums, but I don't have a kit/mics or software to do it. If you want to give it a go with whatever resources you have, that would be greatly appreciated.


A forum bro here once recorded live drums for a song I wrote and it came out great --- you can listen to that here --- pretty awesome!
 
Re: Need mixdown help

I think I can do all of that, but probably not before the weekend. 4 day work week for me = 5 days' work in 4 day's time...
 
Re: Need mixdown help

Here is the final mix of "Chicken Fried." Thanks to all who helped! I ended up mixing and mastering it myself, but taking huge cues from you guys - thanks a million! Both recordings sound like the compression / limiting is slammin' --- I have some compression on both of these, but the hard limiting effect must come from the soundcloud encoding process - these were uploaded as 200 MB wav files, so I imagine there was a lot of fat to trim in those files.

http://soundcloud.com/hunterjsmith/chicken-fried-9

Also, some context:

The singer is my friend Kyle. His brother, Brent, who was like a big brother to me, was killed in a car accident about 2 months ago - a tree fell on the car his family was in, killed him instantly. His wife and daughter were in the back and came out just fine.

Brent loved the Zac Brown Band, and so Kyle and I sang these songs at his funeral to remember my honorary and his real big brother.

That's why you may notice that the lyrics are switched around a little bit.

Kyle wanted to record the songs so we could send them out to his friends and family since a lot of people at the funeral were kind of moved at the inadvertent significance of some of the lyrics. A lot of folks also like hearing Kyle, although he's just an average singer, sing these songs about his brother.

Here is the other song we sang, "Toes." Lots of weirdly significant lyrics in this one.

http://soundcloud.com/hunterjsmith/toes-7

284314_10150253741834118_711629117_7550971_7220067_n.jpg

Kyle (left), Brent (right)​
 
Last edited:
Re: Need mixdown help

Hey, cool!

I really wanted to give this a shot, but a. I totally over-committed myself, as usual, and b. the song just didn't speak to me ... ya know? Great tune, just couldn't get into it enough to work on it.
 
Re: Need mixdown help

Hey, cool!

I really wanted to give this a shot, but a. I totally over-committed myself, as usual, and b. the song just didn't speak to me ... ya know? Great tune, just couldn't get into it enough to work on it.

Yeah, I know exactly what you mean.

For what it's worth, Kyle thinks they both sound great, he's very thankful for the production, and is amazed that we were able to do these recordings with a $60 DAW (Reaper) a $100 microphone (Snowball). It is amazing what you can make in your basement these days.
 
Back
Top