Hi All.
I'm new to the forums (and Duncans), but I've been playing for longer than I'd care to admit
I was hoping for some advice for pickups in two different gutiars. I play a lot of hard rock/metal from van halen to ratt to gnr to dream theater to satch and vai. I'm looking to copy anyone's tone, i just want something that works for me.
Gutiar 1: Frankenstrat. Warmoth maple neck with ebony board. mahogany body. HSS config and a locking trem. This was my main axe for over a decade and it had a Tom Anderson H3 pickup in the bridge. I still love the H3 for solo work, but my tastes have changed and find that it's a bit muddy and flubby for rhythms and not tight at all. I tried swapping in a dimarzio evolution that i had kicking around (hated it in my rg550.. thought that the mahogany body might tame the shrillness.. no such luck). I've seen some vids of the suhr doug aldrich pup and that impressed me. there are some bareknuckles that seem interesting, but i can't justify that kind of coin on a pup. I'd love an H3 that is tighter and more defined for rhythm playing. This guitar usually has light top heavy bottom strings 9-46. Whatever I put in here MUST be 4-conductor.
Guitar 2: PRS SE 245.
Stock pups are 'ok' but maybe a bit too vintage-y for me. they don't really work for me when it comes to more modern playing. They kind of get flubby when you start playing fast palm muting. I don't like how they sound when i play lower tunings. Some guys on the PRS forums are raving over BKP Mules, but again, i can't justify that price tag. I'd like to get something with nickle covers to get that vintage look, but with a modern tone. There's a guy near me who's selling a JB/jazz with chrome covers, but i don't want chrome. I know this is a classic set for a les paul, but would this work for D or Db tunings? I'm kind of flexible on 2-conductor or 4-conductor. AGain, I was thinking about the doug aldrich pups or maybe alnico II's but I'm not sure how the A2 or slash pups would handle high gain metal.
kind of off topic a bit, but I love the low friction Bourns pots in the EVH guitars. Do they make a low friction push/pull version of this pot?
Thanks for looking!
Tim
Edit: one thing that I forgot to add, and I'm really anal about this. When I'm playing and hit a chord, I want to be able to hear every single note in that chord ring out, not have it sound like a flubby mess. I want something that keeps definition, is tight, but is still warm. The one thing I *HATE* about the evolution is the shrillness of it.
I'm new to the forums (and Duncans), but I've been playing for longer than I'd care to admit
I was hoping for some advice for pickups in two different gutiars. I play a lot of hard rock/metal from van halen to ratt to gnr to dream theater to satch and vai. I'm looking to copy anyone's tone, i just want something that works for me.
Gutiar 1: Frankenstrat. Warmoth maple neck with ebony board. mahogany body. HSS config and a locking trem. This was my main axe for over a decade and it had a Tom Anderson H3 pickup in the bridge. I still love the H3 for solo work, but my tastes have changed and find that it's a bit muddy and flubby for rhythms and not tight at all. I tried swapping in a dimarzio evolution that i had kicking around (hated it in my rg550.. thought that the mahogany body might tame the shrillness.. no such luck). I've seen some vids of the suhr doug aldrich pup and that impressed me. there are some bareknuckles that seem interesting, but i can't justify that kind of coin on a pup. I'd love an H3 that is tighter and more defined for rhythm playing. This guitar usually has light top heavy bottom strings 9-46. Whatever I put in here MUST be 4-conductor.
Guitar 2: PRS SE 245.
Stock pups are 'ok' but maybe a bit too vintage-y for me. they don't really work for me when it comes to more modern playing. They kind of get flubby when you start playing fast palm muting. I don't like how they sound when i play lower tunings. Some guys on the PRS forums are raving over BKP Mules, but again, i can't justify that price tag. I'd like to get something with nickle covers to get that vintage look, but with a modern tone. There's a guy near me who's selling a JB/jazz with chrome covers, but i don't want chrome. I know this is a classic set for a les paul, but would this work for D or Db tunings? I'm kind of flexible on 2-conductor or 4-conductor. AGain, I was thinking about the doug aldrich pups or maybe alnico II's but I'm not sure how the A2 or slash pups would handle high gain metal.
kind of off topic a bit, but I love the low friction Bourns pots in the EVH guitars. Do they make a low friction push/pull version of this pot?
Thanks for looking!
Tim
Edit: one thing that I forgot to add, and I'm really anal about this. When I'm playing and hit a chord, I want to be able to hear every single note in that chord ring out, not have it sound like a flubby mess. I want something that keeps definition, is tight, but is still warm. The one thing I *HATE* about the evolution is the shrillness of it.
Last edited:
