NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

benji657

New member
I never thought I'd ever sell the les paul standard that i bragged so much about.
G.jpg

However, I did. I sold it for a PRS. I bet some of you might be going :eyecrazy:. I thought I was too.

Long story short, the les paul wasn't doing it for me. Each time i grabbed it to play, there was always one thing or another that would bug me (the bad nut, the terrible neck joint, the two seam back, etc.)

If you want to see what a production weight relieved gibson les paul looks like:
CHLP1.jpg


I'm sorry, but I'd rather not call that a solid body guitar.

My bigger problem is the neck joint.
tenonhalf.jpg

the upper picture represents the production usa standards.
the lower tenon represents the historic line.

Because of that rather pathetic seesaw tenon, the neck angle on the production les pauls are all over the place. My friends custom has the stoptail cranked down all the way, but because my gibson's neck angle was way too steep, the action had to be set relatively high, and the stoptail had to be too (not to mention the fat nashville bridge contributing to the issue).

I had to be honest to myself. For that kind of mediocre (and i'm being very generous) quality, my 2300 bucks were wasted.
Looking back, I have to admit I bought the les paul for the gibson brand name, and not as an instrument of my own that i'd have for my lifetime.
And as a company who boasts the history of their 1950s les pauls, i have to say, the production les pauls sound nowhere close to the vintage ones.

I tried out multiple PRSs. Custom 24, Custom 22, Tremonti, Singlecuts, McCartys (trems/stoptails).

There was one that just vibrated like crazy. It was a McCarty 10 top with birds, in a natural maple (?) finish. Gold hardware, stoptail, and a solid rosewood neck to die for. I've never held such a gorgeous neck before. I dont know what the exact profile is, (do they call it wide-fat?) but it reminded me of my classical guitar that i prize highly.

Fit my hands like a glove. I looked over everything: perfect neck angle, spot on intonation, nice action, everything, even the pickup height. I could not find one single thing to ***** about, besides my fingerprints. Dare I say, i love the pickups as well (it was probably the sum of all the parts anyway). Everything i disliked about the les paul design was improved on the mccarty: the headstock angle, the neck joint, better quality wood, straight angle for the string to pass through on the nut, ability to split humbuckers via a push pull pot.

Most people say a production les paul should sustain longer than a mccarty should. The biggest thing i hated about my les paul was that while it would seem to sustain forever, the note just choked and died out so suddenly. The McCarty on the other hand, sustained forever, and when the note was close to dying out, it would feedback in a pleasant overtone.

The way I'm describing it seems like I'm exaggerating things a bit. However, i could assure you that i even had a stopwatch with me for the sustain test.

It was a hard decision to sell my les paul, but it was a no-brainer when i played the mccarty. It is much lighter than the les paul, and i think it's just as light as my fender strat. Maybe lighter. I have to say, PRS guitars are some of the most well made guitars i've ever played in my life. The playability is incredible. People criticize them for having no "soul," but I've got no idea what that means. Maybe it's too slick and perfect? I like my instruments to be perfect.

Heck, my fender mim strat stayed with me all these years. My gibson couldn't.

Here are the obligatory photos:
DSC_5229.jpg

DSC_5225.jpg

DSC_5224.jpg

DSC_5223.jpg

DSC_5226.jpg

DSC_5237.jpg
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Very nice. How does the all rosewood neck sound compared to mahogany or maple?
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

welcome to the PRS McCarty family, great guitars. Throw some 11 gauge strings on there and it will sound beefy as hell and sustain forever. A PG in the neck also sounds smokin' in these guitars, I think a brobucker would complament a McCarty nice too. I have a standard model with no thrills, all mahog and dot inlays. I'd like to get my hands on a higher end McCarty. These babies also go for decent prices used, kind of a forgotten friend in the PRS line I feel.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Very nice. How does the all rosewood neck sound compared to mahogany or maple?

since there are more variables that separate the mccarty from the mahogany necked les paul, i can't say for sure. The mccarty sounds cleaner and more elegant, but the low notes have a very dense quality to them.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Amazing :D I love everything about that PRS (even though I normally don't really like natural finishes). Excellent buy!

Also, I knew Gibson's quality was iffy, but man...
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

the chambered thing really is a technicallity. if you like the sound, then use it. if you don't, then dont use it. don't worry about how much wood is there and that BS
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

the chambered thing really is a technicallity. if you like the sound, then use it. if you don't, then dont use it. don't worry about how much wood is there and that BS

i'm sorry my friend, but i dont think it's BS. Think about why they're drilling holes in the first place. and plus, i've outlined other reasons why i think the gibson wasn't worth the 2300 bucks.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Awww, c'mon - PRS guitars are garbage. How could you ever get rid of your tone machine of a Les Paul? You got screwed and you didn't even know it...














Btw, that one's a beauty - congrats!
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

i'm sorry my friend, but i dont think it's BS. Think about why they're drilling holes in the first place. and plus, i've outlined other reasons why i think the gibson wasn't worth the 2300 bucks.

I mean you are entitled to your opinion, and I fully agree that a gibson is in no way shape or form worth that much. but its not because theres holes in it. its because I just don't have that kind of money and because I don't like the guitars....with a few exceptions of course
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Sounds like a good move, man. Only you can tell if it was good, but I'm sure it was.
I did try a McCarty once and it was a sick, sick guitar. Definitely on my "to get" list.
Congratulations on the new axe, it looks stunning!
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

oh yeah, forgot to mention: PRSs rock! I've got an SE Soapbar. personal favorite. and the non SE models are way sicker
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

That axe is drop dead sexy:naughty: I love the way the gold hardware and the natural maple top look together, very elegant. She would look slick with some double cream pups.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

happy for ya

nice loookin axe and sounds like she plays and sounds just as good - way to go!

did you buy it new or preowned? .... if you do not have the hangtag, call PRS customer servidce and read em the serial number ... they'll give you an exact list out of the specs/details ... with a solid rosewood neck, that is not an average mccarty ... might be a limited edition ... you can find out which number it is out of how many total were made

enjoy
t4d
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

Wow, stunning guitar.... congrats it's gorgeous!! I want a MacRosie too but I doubt I will lucky enough to get one as nice as yours. All the best with that, great stuff.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

I've played a flame-top sunburst McCarty (pretty sure it had dot inlays though) and it played like a dream and sounded amazing (my friend had put in a PG+ and a neck bucker he made with two Lace Sensors.

Your new McCarty is gorgeous, I can't see why anyone would ever part with such a piece of art, so if you ever do, it will be over my head.

The only way they could make a McCarty a "must-have" for me though would be to offer a dual P-90 version.
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

cool man.

i wish they looked different. i like everything about PRS except their shape and style. The awesome tops and primo wood is awesome and their construction is top notch, but i can't gel with the necks and they just don't look 'right' to me.

if i could get a Gibson SG built to the standards of a PRS it'd be about my perfect guitar. the Mira is close but still looks too PRS-like for me...:smokin:
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

happy for ya

nice loookin axe and sounds like she plays and sounds just as good - way to go!

did you buy it new or preowned? .... if you do not have the hangtag, call PRS customer servidce and read em the serial number ... they'll give you an exact list out of the specs/details ... with a solid rosewood neck, that is not an average mccarty ... might be a limited edition ... you can find out which number it is out of how many total were made

enjoy
t4d


Eh, the solid rosewood neck is just an extra option, as is the bird inlays and 10 tops. It's not a limited edition McCarty by any means, but it is one sexy beast of a guitar!
 
Re: NGD: PRS McCarty 10 Top Birds.

That's one of the most awesome guitars ever, and even though your LP looked cool, some Gibsons just aren't as good as the others.
 
Back
Top