Haven't AB'd it with a Plimsoul, but I did have a shoot out with a Lovepedal Superlead. The Superlead was shockingly awesome.
*** with humbuckers only so far ***
OCD: crispier
Plim: squishier
OCD: more 80s & 90s
Plim: more 70s
OCD: more Scorpions
Plim: more Gojira
OCD: more waxed
Plim: more hairy
OCD: tighter
Plim: looser
:fest6: New Pedal Shootout Day
Plim: way more versatile and complex, like a streamlined GT-500
Plimsoul is heavier. Has more crust. Ideal for djent players. A broader sounding distortion, a "fuller" distortion if you will, and more of it. The OCD showed me how to dial in the Plimsoul to get more out of it. There is so much distortion in that Plimsoul and so much granular variance in the controls that it can get tricky to dial yer thing in, and it can get raspy if yer not careful.
It also cleans up more musically than the OCD.
I'm keeping the OCD because it has an inherent go-to sound that I like and I don't need to tweak. And the palette between the two will take me a while to mine.
All I can say is I'm not frustrated by the goings on, instead these pedals are fun, comfortable, and complementary to each other. They're like brothers I don't think I could separate.
The Plimsoul is NOT an OCD v.5, at all. Get that right outta yer mind, dear reader.
It does win, however.
Do you have a GT-500? Can you throw how that compares into the mix too?
Can you start a thread about 'Djent"? That one east Indian dude who plays a 7 string who does some demonstrations is good. This is a Genre that I identify with.
What kinda pickups are you using? I definatly feel you on the OCD=Scorps and Plimsoul = Gojira. I used the Plim for rythem and the fulldrive for lead for a bit. Both the OCD and Plim can be a little scooped for lead to me.
While fulldrive is tighter, it isn't as amp like. All fun.