Hi! I am interested in swapping magnets in my dual P90 Gibson SG Classic. Especially the bridge pickup could use some extra beef and some taming of the highs. I found out that standard Gibson P90's have two A5 magnets, which, according to most people, can be really bright indeed.
After some reading I discovered that the A8 magnet is the thing for me. They should give my pickup more low/mids and output. However, I am not really clear about mixing different types. Some say it's okay to put an A5 with an A8 in one P90, others say that the stronger magnet will 'degauss' the lighter magnet, causing further decrease of power in that lighter magnet. I cannot find how long it will take for one magnet to negatively affect the other magnet to a point that it will be audible. Q1: Does anyone know?
Because of this controversy, and the fact that all commercial P90 producers I could find (SD, DiMarzio, Rio Grande, Bare Knuckle, etc) only use ONE type of magnet, I think I will take the safe route and order two A8's for my bridge pickup.
Then there's the neck pickup. It could be a little less boomy and could use some high/mids. Some P90 producers use A2's, others use A3's. Q2: What do you peole here recommend?
Finally, there's a question about orientation. I found out that magnets should repel. That means either south and south should be together or north and north. But does it matter which part of the magnet is up and which part is down? If your pickups lay south to south and you flip one over over the length of the magnet, they still lay south to south, but another side is now up. Q3: Does this have any influence? Or shouldn't up/down matter, only north/south?
Ah yes, the actual final question! About the whole RWRP thing. The standard Gibson P90's do not come in RWRP sets, so every pickup has either south to south or north to north. Let's say it's south to south and I put in new magnets. Do they also have to be south to south? If I put the new magnets north to north in, the pickups will be RP, but not RW. Q4: Could this cause phase problems when using both pickups or doesn't it matter?
Lots of questions, I hope you nice people here can help me. Thanks in advance!!
After some reading I discovered that the A8 magnet is the thing for me. They should give my pickup more low/mids and output. However, I am not really clear about mixing different types. Some say it's okay to put an A5 with an A8 in one P90, others say that the stronger magnet will 'degauss' the lighter magnet, causing further decrease of power in that lighter magnet. I cannot find how long it will take for one magnet to negatively affect the other magnet to a point that it will be audible. Q1: Does anyone know?
Because of this controversy, and the fact that all commercial P90 producers I could find (SD, DiMarzio, Rio Grande, Bare Knuckle, etc) only use ONE type of magnet, I think I will take the safe route and order two A8's for my bridge pickup.
Then there's the neck pickup. It could be a little less boomy and could use some high/mids. Some P90 producers use A2's, others use A3's. Q2: What do you peole here recommend?
Finally, there's a question about orientation. I found out that magnets should repel. That means either south and south should be together or north and north. But does it matter which part of the magnet is up and which part is down? If your pickups lay south to south and you flip one over over the length of the magnet, they still lay south to south, but another side is now up. Q3: Does this have any influence? Or shouldn't up/down matter, only north/south?
Ah yes, the actual final question! About the whole RWRP thing. The standard Gibson P90's do not come in RWRP sets, so every pickup has either south to south or north to north. Let's say it's south to south and I put in new magnets. Do they also have to be south to south? If I put the new magnets north to north in, the pickups will be RP, but not RW. Q4: Could this cause phase problems when using both pickups or doesn't it matter?
Lots of questions, I hope you nice people here can help me. Thanks in advance!!
Last edited:
