Pinch harmonics and actives?

papersoul

New member
Guys,

Why is it that actives like EMGs are better at pinch harmonics ala Zack comared to passives? What is it...the low impedance of the pickup? just curious!

Thanks!!
Rich
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

They are? I personally have never thought the pickup had anything to go with getting pinch harmonics. I've always thought it was about style and technique myself.....but that's just me.:dunno:
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

I know what you mean, and jolly is right. but if your wonderin why zakks harmonics squeal the way they do (correct me if i'm wrong) but that has something to do with a wah pedal. if you own a wah pedal mess around with some really high gain leads and pinch harmonics in the higher frequencies, you'll see what i mean. it'll hurt your ears :D
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

It ain't the wah pedal. He double tracks the harmonics on his albums, and live, it's the tubes. Tubes are much easier to get good pinch harmonics from than SS or modeling. Even so, F@ck Zakk, me and Jolly are the PH kings!!!
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

I didn't realize tubes made pinch harmonics easier! Interesting. I use a Line 6 Vetta II head and it's decent with pinch harmonics but could be better. Maybe that's the real answer.

Plus, i have to say Jolly has some clips that make me drull.....amazing pinch harmonics! Good technique!

I also would never think the wah pedal would play a part.

What got me interested was I know a guy who has EMGs in all of his LPs. He plays in a cover band and gets insane pinch harmonics live so I thought it was a combination of technique and EMGs. Most guys will admit that certain pickups do make it easier. Check these clips out...
http://thesamhillband.com/
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

DeadSkinSlayer3 said:
me and Jolly are the PH kings!!!

ahem :rolleyes:


You can get some of the best pinch harmonics with a modelling setup, and with tubes alike. And just the same you can get tube rigs that dont like pinch hamonics at all if they're not set up properly.

Its in the fingers, and having a setup with really focussed gain helps a lot. But mainly its the player and its the pickups used, ie. a fullsize JB in the bridge will get pinch harmonics happening a lot easier and better sounding than a strat antiquity neck pickup!

But its gotta be in the fingers and technique, or it doesnt matter what you're playing on.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

OK ok fine...Jolly and I :laugh2: :fing25: ;)
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

you crazy kids lol I think EMG's make them easier because they're more tuned to higher frequencies.. in my opinion the pup has the most to do with it
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

DeadSkinSlayer3 said:
OK ok fine...Jolly and I :laugh2: :fing25: ;)

No, just Jolly.

just think about it this way, you unplug your guitar and do a pinch harmonic and you can barely hear it. the lower the output of the pickup, the harder it is for it to pick that up. you'll find most high output pickups get better PH, because they're louder. and active pickups are extremely high output...

SD Tone Chart said:
JB - Super harmonics, with high output that doesn't sound hard or dark.
DD - Hot and bright with harmonics galore.
Livewire Heavy Metal - Tons of mids, harmonics, sustain and incredible output.
Pearly Gates - a bright top that make harmonics jump out of the guitar.

Need i say more?
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

i don't think pinch harmonics is something only associated with active pickups.Active pickups as a design have certain caracteristics like the fact they are extremely quiet e.t.c but i think passive pickups can do pinch armonics equally well.My JB is perfect for pinch harmonics.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Young Angus said:
My JB is perfect for pinch harmonics too, it loves them!
Same here with my JB. But in the same guitar and setup, the Custom wouldn't yield near the same pinch harmonics.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Go read "neck pickups with 24 fret guitars" and pinch on a node. You've got to get the harmonic before you can intensify it's tone with distortion or setting up the bias on the amp (like a marshall 900) or running your delay at 80ms single repeat or what ever. EMGs...read an artical on them when the came out that killed my intrest...2k pickup (low z enough to supress hum) with a preamp to get the gain above the out put of a hi z pickup. Sounds like your giving up your tone to get a minature Boss Blues Driver installed in your guitar. I think I'd rather have my pickups and a Keely moded Blues Driver, or just a Blues Driver...there great stock. Someone please kindy enlighten me if this is not the case with the 85 model…I think that’s the one everyone talks about.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

I've had 2 guitars with EMGs, one with single coils and one with humbuckers and I found the tone of both to be harsh and sterile compared to good passive pickups. I have no problem getting pinch harmonics with either my PRS Cu22 or my McNaught Phoenix.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Lightning said:
2k pickup (low z enough to supress hum) with a preamp to get the gain above the out put of a hi z pickup.
Well that explains a lot... pretty interesting. They could at least change the pickup/preamp output ratio a little bit. I could see that being a little bit of a good idea with a single coil... but not a humbucker. I never have problems with noise on a humbucker, the noise single coils have doesn't even bother me that much. Like it matters, you really don't even notice it when your playing anyway... to me it sounds like the makers of EMG were concentrating a little more on noise cancelation and a lot less on tone...
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Pickups really DO matter. My dad used to have a Peavey T-60 that played really well, and sounded good, but the pups were so sterile that you couldn't FORCE harmonics out of it. On the other hand, I remember playing a Yamaha guitar (years ago) that was so lively that I couldn't control the harmonics (maybe I could now, who knows). That thing squealed at the slightest touch.

I also find that bridge pups are better are amplifying harmonics, especially when combined with a compressor and distortion. And if you're into it, Wah helps, too.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

papersoul said:
Guys,

Why is it that actives like EMGs are better at pinch harmonics ala Zack comared to passives? What is it...the low impedance of the pickup? just curious!

Thanks!!
Rich
nah it is the player not the pup trust me i used to know zakk when he played in clubs and i know for a fact that ZAKK could nail those pinch harmonics with ANY pup
:cool3:
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Jolly does it find with the Custom and PG so maybe I am way wrong. I still find certain pickups do a better job in my opnion.
 
Re: Pinch harmonics and actives?

Cory_Dylan said:
Well that explains a lot... pretty interesting. They could at least change the pickup/preamp output ratio a little bit. I could see that being a little bit of a good idea with a single coil... but not a humbucker. I never have problems with noise on a humbucker, the noise single coils have doesn't even bother me that much. Like it matters, you really don't even notice it when your playing anyway... to me it sounds like the makers of EMG were concentrating a little more on noise cancelation and a lot less on tone...
Yeah, it's in the fingers, but the right tonal emphasis helps it to jump out even more, be it amp, pedals, or pups ... Concerning EMG's I never care for them personally ... the actual idea makes great sense though .... that being that you can wind the pup to get the exact tone (bandwidth) that you want, with the exact string pull you want, and then adjust it's output separately, and make any additional tonal changes you need. Rather than the passive game of compromise of tone, string pull, and output ... as they are all effected when you change one, you chnge the others also. I think EMG's might be great for bass, or for getting a really flat (direct box) type tone.
 
Back
Top