Rosewood or Mahogany Back and Sides?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Heretic
  • Start date Start date
H

Heretic

Guest
I intend to buy an acoustic guitar. I have my eyes on a Martin D-18 and D-28 with Mahogany and Rosewood backs/sides respectively. What is the difference between the two sonically/tonally especially that they both have Spruce tops?

Thanks!
 
Re: Rosewood or Mahogany Back and Sides?

On Larger body guitars such as Dreadnaught guitars Mahogony has better balance from string to string. Mahogony will not be as boomy as Rosewood in this size. I have a D18, and I love it. I also have a Santa Cruz Tony Rice model, which is essentially a D28 with an oversized soundhole. They are both excellent guitars. I prefer the Santa Cruz, but it has nothing to do with the wood. I use the D18 for open G and some open D work. The Santa Cruz I use more for standard tuned stuff, and droppped D. The Mahogony has a nice warm even tone when I drop the tuning. I also prefer Mahogony in a smaller body size. I would recommend you look at a OMV 18 as well. This is a less expensive model and for some players they feel it is a more versatile guitar. Large body guitars are more difficult for fingerpicking. They are better suited for strumming and flatpicking, you got to hit them pretty hard to get the sound out of a big box. A small body guitar takes less effort to get it to project. It really has a lot to do with the style of music, and your particular playing style. They are all really good guitars.
 
Re: Rosewood or Mahogany Back and Sides?

I love the way rosewood looks!

certainly nothing wrong with the tone of mahogany, though

Bludave's right about smaller bodies being better for fingerpicking, due to the shorter scale. Like the difference between a strat and Les Paul - a noticeable difference in tension.
 
Re: Rosewood or Mahogany Back and Sides?

in general rosewood is a brighter more articulate wood than mahogany - the above is a pretty good answer though
 
Re: Rosewood or Mahogany Back and Sides?

i really enjoy the sound of my martin with rosewood sides and back. very nice smooth and articulate
 
Back
Top