Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

Jazzfiend101

New member
Of course it can be done, but is it the best option for me? Hey guys, I've got some questions regarding this relatively new pickup that SeyDunc has given us, the Black Winter! It looks to me like it's the most metal thing to have come out since I don't know when. The ye-olde-english font, the WWII graphics, it all screams heavy metal to my ears, but the problem I'm getting is that the few youtube reviews I've seen on it seem to be down tuned all the way to the depths of Hell!

I get that these things are marketed towards the blackest of the Scandinavian metalcore freaks out there, but I'm a bit of a rule breaker. I tend to be the guy who wants to use something for the opposite purposes of why it was invented in the first place. I play in a cover band that does mostly hard rock stuff. We play Guns N Roses stuff, Metallica, and even our Lady Gaga covers are pretty heavy. I had initially started out using lower output pickups like the Pearly Gates and I just never bonded well with that one, or the Alnico 2 Pro bridge. I want a bit more output so I can dial my distortion on my Orange Dark Terror down a bit. I'm running that 15w bad boy through two 1x12 Orange cabs with V30s installed in them.

The guitar in question is an Epiphone Les Paul Custom and it currently has the JB/Jazz neck combo in it. It's a great set, no lie, but I've got 3 Les Pauls, one with a set of 59s (which suprisingly rock super hard from anything to blues to Master of Puppets I'm satisfied with that set) then I have another Les Paul with an Alnico 2 Pro neck which is awesome, and a Pearly Gates in the bridge which I have decided isn't my cup of cake at all. I'd had plans to actually return the JB from the white Les Paul Custom to its other brother and original owner which now has the Pearly Gates, and the PG will probably be going in the dresser drawer for some time (I'm a hoarder).

Initially I was shopping to find just one replacement bridge for the Pearly Gates until I decided I would just stick the JB (which sounded better in that guitar than the white Custom, in my opinion) to its original owner and just get a whole new set of pickups for the white Custom, follow? I decided I wanted a guitar that would go all out balls to the wall hard rock/metal, a real killer sound with cutting leads and good looks to boot. I went through my options: there is always the EMGs of which there are only 100 I have to choose from. I'm a big Zakk Wylde fan so I already know that will work. But I have to be super difficult before I'm satisfied. I checked out the Blackouts and they seem to only just slightly outperform the EMGs (lets not start an EMG/Blackout argument here, I have decided that the Blackouts are better to my ears) and then I started looking at Distortion, but meh, and then there is the Full Shred which is also a meh. I got the idea in my head to stick a set of Invaders in the Les Paul but I had everyone but my mother who all said, "NO BILLY DOn'T DO IT! IT'LL SOUND LIKE MUD!" so I steered clear of it. But that massive high output was so intriguing.

Now, the Black Winters seem to have a fairly balanced EQ running at 6/6/6 (could it be any more evil) with an output to match the Invader. So, already I'm wondering two things, could it work with a Les Paul tuned to Eflat standard tuning, and would that neck pickup clean up well enough to make a decent clean sound (Orange Dark Terror is a single channel and I use my neck pups to generate my clean sound coupled with a BOSS super chorus for added sparkle and it works great for my tastes). I'm trying to believe that the flat eq with the Black Winters would basically just add a helluva lot more output to a guitar that already has a similarly rated output with a JB. While I am shooting for versatility, it isn't beyond me to split those coils for more tonal variety. I know if I stick these pickups in yes I'm limiting me options, but that's sorta why I have two other guitars with lower out put pickups. Also, I've come to the conclusion that with enough distortion even the lowest of output pickups can provide a decent hard rock sound. That's what Slash told me. So I'm guessing in order to compensate all I'd have to do in between songs/switching guitars I'd just have to knock the gain down a level or two.

So, thoughts? Discuss!
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

Well I can tell you that the Distortion bridge is not "meh".

Not a lot of people know anything about these pickups beyond the demos that SD has released. You might just want to get a set and plug em in for a few days. SD has a 30 day return policy so if they don't meet your standards after a month, return them and get a Hot rodded humbucker set.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

The Black Winter pups will do damn near anything you want. With my set I can get Metal, Classic rock, tones that wander into Country Twang territory, and the cleans are very chimey and pristine. They're very versatile. They're currently in one of my Jackson King Vs, but am planning on putting them in my Epi Les Paul Custom (the one in my avatar pic).

Everything you may want to know probably has been answered here: https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?262447-Black-Winter-owner-Feedback-so-far
 
Last edited:
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

There is literally no pup[ that you can't do most styles of music with.

And the Distortion is not 'meh' at all.

Also, flip the A2P/PGb. Put the PG in the neck, and A2P in the bridge.

The flat eq will put out the true EQ of the guitar - whatever that is for an Epi Custom.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

one thing i can tell you is if you want your neck pickup to clean up dont go for anything active besides maybe the gus g fire blackouts, another thing is the invaders are indeed to "muddy" for what youre doing (they preform best with scooped mids), the distortion and full shred are great if youre using alot of mid range, it sounds like youre satisfied with your jb, and if it aint broke why try and fix it, but for balls to the wall the BWs are right up that alley. aswell as the gus g fire blackouts. but its your decision and yours alone so choose wisely.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

one thing i can tell you is if you want your neck pickup to clean up dont go for anything active besides maybe the gus g fire blackouts, another thing is the invaders are indeed to "muddy" for what youre doing (they preform best with scooped mids), the distortion and full shred are great if youre using alot of mid range, it sounds like youre satisfied with your jb, and if it aint broke why try and fix it, but for balls to the wall the BWs are right up that alley. aswell as the gus g fire blackouts. but its your decision and yours alone so choose wisely.

The Invader is best with scooped mids?? I feel like that would muddy it up even more. I could be wrong

And the distortion is fantastic, although maybe it's not for everyone
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

All pups are fantastic at something or they wouldn't exist.

Now, in YOUR guitar (wood, construction), with YOUR amp (SS, Tube, HB, low/med/High gain...), and playing YOUR music...that's a whole other issue.

Slap a tight delay on an Invader, no reverb, turn the gain down, scoop the miss, in a brightish guitar....it is probably wicked. In a mahogany mud ball short scale with high gain? Yuck.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

Guys thank you all for your responses. I'm certainly not dissing the Distortion by no means. It's a best seller no doubt. I'm kinda weird, I don't like using what everybody else is using, I tend to trod off the beaten path. I once heard of a blues guy in my town who used a Gibson Les Paul loaded with Full Shreds and through a Fender Twin and this guy's tone was unreal because he just went way left of center with his pickups, and he was already a really good player to boot, too. I do like my JB, maybe there are a couple of things about it I would like more, such as a tighter bottom. Orange amps seem to have this sag to them and with my ODT15 that's no exception. It's not bad or highly noticable, but I also find that the JB has just a touch of sag to it as well, so sometimes when I'm doing the chugga chugga, for instance, we play AC/DC's "Whole Lotta Rosie" and I literally downpick every part of that song except for the solo I came up with for it.... I notice that the JB drags occassionally.

Let me say something off subject here about Orange amplification: I tend to notice that with Orange amps you tend to really have to work a little harder, and play a little tighter to get the right sounds to come from your guitar and in to your amp. I'm not sure if anyone else feels me on that, but what I mean to say is that you tend to have to tighten up a lot with an Orange sorta like you have to do a Plexi. You gotta be really on point because those kinds of amps really will articulate your mistakes pretty loudly! Just a personal opinion. So, some times when I feel the JB drags I switch to my Epi with the 59 set and guess who's happy? This guy.

I have DEF thought about sticking a Pearly Gates neck in one of my Les Pauls, as I hear the general consensus with that set is the neck is usually more preferred over the bridge. I'm no fan of the bridge and I tried for years to use it through different combos and hey... I just don't like it. =\ But I still love Billy Gibbons. Huge influence.

Back on point- with the Black Winters I really do feel that since I have never really stepped into high output territory beyond what the JB has to offer, I'm thinking that since

A)I don't feel like dropping money on actives because they are the expensive
B)I'd like to minimize my installation to just changing pickups, instead of fiddling with battery packs and what not

...then I might as well go with a passive for now so that I can just sorta keep it in the family with the rest of my setup. I think with the Black Winter's flat EQ it'd give me more options than say... the Invader, as far as a Les Paul is concerned.

Another thing to mention, beyond my broad taste of music I decided to buy the latest Avenged Sevenfold album, and I noticed that the dude with the Invaders really isn't that distorted, he's got a pretty clear sound, or a clear and coherent distortion. His sound is more like... powerful. So I know this guy doesn't dime his gain all the way out and I'm thinking that if I could do that with the Black Winters than I may could be able to pull off some cool stuff.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

Thank you very much for that link to the Black Winters. That has helped infinitely. I think I'm gonna buy these as it seems they can be made to be versatile high out put rock machines. The devil be damned; I'm gonna play Lady Gaga and rock faces with these puppies. I'll place an order soon and hopefully we'll hit the nail on the head with them!
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

I threw my set in my Les Paul today. I've only had the chance to try them through my little Peavey Vypyr so far (didn't have the house to myself, so I couldn't crank up the Splawn or the Marshall), but so far they are just as bright as the Gibson 500T/496R set that I had in there before, but the Winters aren't harsh like the Gibsons were. I'll take it to practice tomorrow and run it thriugh my Mesa and see what happens.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

I replaced the burstbucker pro's in my Les Paul with the winters a few weeks ago. Through my Mesa mini rec they sound amazing and are actually quite versatile. They also don't seem to be as harsh sounding as the stock pickups were. I like them so much that I may order a 7 string set for my Schecter.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

I placed an order for 2 trembucker bridge BWs but Cascio had to special order them right from Duncan. Told me Duncan is backordered and it will be 2-4 weeks. Good to see these are selling out and they are backordered, sucks for me because I have a longer wait now.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

Do want.

I'm tearing myself apart trying to decide on a bridge bucker for my Viper. I'm yanking the passive EMGs and putting a hum sized P90 in the neck a la Pepper Keenan. But can't pick what to put in the bridge position.
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

I threw my set in my Les Paul today. I've only had the chance to try them through my little Peavey Vypyr so far (didn't have the house to myself, so I couldn't crank up the Splawn or the Marshall), but so far they are just as bright as the Gibson 500T/496R set that I had in there before, but the Winters aren't harsh like the Gibsons were. I'll take it to practice tomorrow and run it thriugh my Mesa and see what happens.
How have the Black Winters turned out for you so far?

Sent from my SM-G920T using Tapatalk
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

All pups are fantastic at something or they wouldn't exist.


Not really true. There's a lot of cheap stock PU's that are put in guitars, basically just to fill the PU cavity. Did you mean to say: 'All high quality PU's are fantastic at something."?
 
Re: Seymour Duncan Black Winter in Epiphone Les Paul! Can it be done??

There's a lot of stock PU's that are put in guitars, basically just to fill the PU cavity
Funny you say that, that's the feeling I get from Gibson p'ups. And don't get me started about stock Epiphone p'ups not belonging to the Probucker and Alnico Classic PRO series. ;)
 
Back
Top