Re: What do I do between amp/guitar volume?
I've gone full circle a few times between setting things pulled back a notch or two, or going full on.
I think my favorite way of doing it is to always having the bridge pickup tone at 8 - 9, with room to move higher, and then set the amp to my liking. I use standard wiring on the guitars, so the volume pulls back a tiny bit of treble as well. I can then ride the volume as needed.
But when I use pickup settings that involve more pickups, I max out the bridge volume and tone. On Gibsons, I mix in the neck volume. On Fenders, the neck is always 10.
Essentially, necks and middles are always 10, and the bridge gets adjusted for the perfect amount of treble bite.