Re: What makes the difference...
Part of it is power tube selection and how hard you push those tubes. Generally 6l6 and el34 amps retain a certain amount of tightness, but if you push 30 watts plus out of four el84s then you'll start to hear some more fuzzbox-like, looser overdrive. However, if you make an EL84 amp run 18 watts, like a marshall 18watter, soldano atomic or Peavey Classic 20, then the amp's overdrive stays pretty tight.
Speakers are a big deal, too. Lower wattage speakers will distort and loosen the tone earlier than higher wattage speakers.
Rectifiers seem to affect the feel of the amp rather than the sound...