Re: What stock pickups would be in a '92 Gibson Les Paul Standard?
[I always like to do things the cheapest, easiest way first. Changing the mags in both of those pups that you already have is certainly the cheapest thing to try before replacing them and may just get you the tone you're after. If not, go ahead and replace one or both of them and you really haven't lost anything (a couple bucks and a few minutes of your time), but you've gained some precious knowledge of what some mag changes can do to your tone.
+1. You nailed it Doc. I've learned a lot on this forum over the years, but
this is the single best advice I've ever gotten. Start off with easy and cheap solutions and work your way up. Many times you'll get what you want for a few dollars, or even for free. Another way I've seen it worded is:
'Work with what you have.' Too many guys get caught up and start throwing money at a problem...and often just create new problems. Think about what you want to accomplish and take it in stages. Slow down and be analytical. If a part, or all of a PU's sound isn't to your liking,
DO NOT automatically rush out and buy another PU (which is often no better of a choice). Figure out
exactly what it is that you don't like, and what you want instead. Adjust your PU and pole piece heights first; it's amazing how many times that solves the problem. Then look at magnets and pots. Every HB and P-90 has a dozen or more personalities; you've seen
one with the stock magnet. Until you try another magnet or two, you have
no idea of what else that PU has to offer. Here's an example: Like many guys I bought several JB's since they've been so heavily promoted (not a good reason to buy a PU as I've since learned), and quickly soured on them and sold them. Just didn't work in mahogany for what I want to do. After-the-fact I saw threads about putting in an A2. I happened to find a lone JB (one I missed when selling them off), put an A2 in it, and it's a
completely different PU. Great in mahogany: warm and full, no ice pick. Fixes everything I didn't like about stock JB's. I'm very glad I didn't give up on JB's. What I learned was that I don't like JB's with A5's; every other magnet in them is on the table for discussion.