Would You....

Would You....


  • Total voters
    19

threechordcharlie

RedTruckologist
Give a 10 year old, 4 string MIM P-bass + $75.00, for a 6 year old Peavey Foundation 5? Or a brand new Squier 5 string for the same trade? Or would you just keep the P-bass?
 
Re: Would You....

I would keep the MIM Precision and spend the seventy five bucks on one of the following;
1) A nicer pickup
2) A chunkier bridge
3) A detuning machinehead for the E string.
 
Re: Would You....

If you are not really dying for a 5 string keep the P bass. If you want a 5 string get the Squire.
 
Re: Would You....

That Peavey is USA made, correct?

I can see no reason not to trade a MIM P-bass for a USA-made bass.

If God had intended for people to stick with 4 string basses, He would not have granted man the wisdom to add a 5th.

Seriously, simplicity is a disease, not a virtue.
 
Re: Would You....

That Peavey is USA made, correct?

I can see no reason not to trade a MIM P-bass for a USA-made bass.

USA or not, it's still a Peavey.............

If it were me, I would sell the Fender MIM on CL or something. It should bring $300 to $350 pretty quick just because it says Fender on the headstock. Take the $350 and troll CL for a Squire 5 string for around $100 to $125, then find the Peavey for the same price and pocket the change. Not sure about where you are from, but Peaveys and Squires don't bring squat on the private used market around here.
 
Re: Would You....

Why not just convert the P bass to a 5 string?

Both of these bases started out as 4 strings. (not mine)

All you need is a new nut, bridge, and a tuner.

F5%20011.jpg
 
Re: Would You....

I'd upgrade the pickups and hardware on the existing bass.

drop something like a quarter pounder in there.
 
Re: Would You....

Why not just convert the P bass to a 5 string?

Both of these bases started out as 4 strings. (not mine)

All you need is a new nut, bridge, and a tuner.

F5%20011.jpg
Dude! More info please.

I'd upgrade the pickups and hardware on the existing bass.

drop something like a quarter pounder in there.
I will do the QP. (funny how time changes things huh?! There was a time when that meant something totaly different for me!)
 
Re: Would You....

USA or not, it's still a Peavey.............

If it were me, I would sell the Fender MIM on CL or something. It should bring $300 to $350 pretty quick just because it says Fender on the headstock. Take the $350 and troll CL for a Squire 5 string for around $100 to $125, then find the Peavey for the same price and pocket the change. Not sure about where you are from, but Peaveys and Squires don't bring squat on the private used market around here.

There is much wisdom in your words.
 
Re: Would You....

That Peavey is USA made, correct?

I can see no reason not to trade a MIM P-bass for a USA-made bass.

If God had intended for people to stick with 4 string basses, He would not have granted man the wisdom to add a 5th.

Seriously, simplicity is a disease, not a virtue.
I agree about the 5 string part, but about the Peavey part, no. When I started out, I played Peavey, these are great basses but they weigh a frikin' ton! 4-5 hours with one of these things hung around your kneck is torture!
 
Re: Would You....

The converted bass guitars in the photograph above show no sign of major modification around the neck pocket area. Therefore, the five string conversion neck is the same width at the heel as a regular four string. Personally, I would find that string spacing too tight - even if the nut width is wider than the typical four string.

This is before we get to the issue of the aligment of five strings over eight polepieces. (Hardly fatal but not ideal.)
 
Re: Would You....

Resale value to the side for a bit...the Peaveys are solid as a rock. If you really want to shake the foundation, look for a T-40 from Peavey. You could use it to pound in nails and it will still be in tune for the gig.
 
Re: Would You....

Resale value to the side for a bit...the Peaveys are solid as a rock. If you really want to shake the foundation, look for a T-40 from Peavey. You could use it to pound in nails and it will still be in tune for the gig.

The T-40 was my very first bass way back when. But you know, back then all Peavey equipment was built to survive a thermonuclear explosion. I had a Mark IV bass head that got a drink spilled into it while I was in the middle of a song. We unplugged it, put it in front of a fan for an hour or so, then it worked like a charm.
It was like they were built to govt. specs.

And BTW: I don't really care about the resale value either. I do, however, get tired of the "name plate" snobs. I guess that's a burden I must bear being an introvert.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top