72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

ChipOnly

New member
Hey guys. Any help in suggesting replacement SDs for this guitar is appreciated. If I can reciprocate when it comes to pedals (my area of expertise!), I'll be happy to! Here's the deal -

I have a MIM 72 Custom tele from around 2000, if you are unfamiliar with the model, it's a three way switch with individual tone and vol pots for each pickup. I have bumped the humbucker at the neck's pots to 500k, and it helped a little, but man, that RI "WRHB" is IMO a woofy and unsalvageable abomination. An upgrade is long overdue - this guitar lives in a case and I'd like to get it back in the rotation, and I know better than to sell my first ever electric (not terribly valuable, a gift from my now deceased father, and I'm sentimental like that). So here I am. Help!

I have no real desire to necessarily cop the original WRHB sound and so I don't feel the need to go for the SD custom shop WRHB, which I'm sure is worth the money but more than I care to put into this guitar right now. I picked up an adapter ring for the pickguard so I can pop a regular HB in the neck. I would like a covered humbucker there for the overall look - it's what attracted my teenage self to the 72 custom in the first place. As far as the bridge goes, I do love a tele single coil bridge sound (that's what makes a tele a tele, to me, and I love the jerry donahue bridge pup I have in another of my teles), but I'm open to something like the little 59 or maybe even a hot rail. My other tele covers all the traditional tele single coil tones well enough, so I feel freed up to hot-rod or modernize this one a little bit.

More than anything, I need a pair that's going to balance well both in terms of output and EQ profile - I do not want to have to adjust anything on my amp or pedals every time I reach for the pick-up selector. I understand that's tricky, and that bridge pups are generally a little louder and cut better, hence the "lead" designation.

I'm finding it very, very hard to decide what route to go. If I had to pick a pair right now, I'd guess I'd go with another jerry donahue in the bridge and a pearly gates at the neck - I'm under the impression the PG is a little brighter than an average bucker but still vintage output, and theorize that it will work nicely with the JD....?

Then I wonder about a hotrail in the bridge and a little bit hotter neck humbucker. Shortly thereafter, I am paralyzed by option-based wonder. My mind is open to your ideas, preferably born of experience.

What sayeth y'all? Thanks again for your help!
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

Welcome to the forum.

Looks as if you are already settled on your choice of single coil bridge position pickup. Do be aware that, if the guitar has the vintage-correct 1Meg pots, the pickup may sound different and traditional Speedy West/Roy Buchanan volume and tone control swell stunts will not turn out the way that you expect.

For the humbucker, your options are limited by the aperture cut into the pickguard. Aftermarket exact retrofitting replacement pickups are available. (An SD SH-1N with Alnico 4 magnet material, under a suitably over-sized metal cover, would be nice.) Also consider the rebuild/rewind services offered by makers such as The Creamery. The stock Fender MIM abomination can form the basis of a perfectly serviceable pickup. This option may work out cheaper than purchasing an entire new pickup.
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

I have a stk-t3b and phat cat in my tele custom.
If I were to start over I'd go stk-t3b and seth lover. No Hum!
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

I'm splitting this, and going for the Jerry Donahue and the Seth Lover. Seths sound great in the neck of a Tele, and the JD is hot enough to compete (and it sounds good too).
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

You have solid suggestions here. If you don't want your WRHB becomes junk, also consider sending it to Telenator for Mod1 Alnico.
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

I know you have an adaptor to use regular buckers, but Mojotone makes a really good Wide Range humbucker.
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

Whew! Long work week (retail + gigs this weekend). I didn't forget about this and appreciate everyone's input. Especially Gibson 175 and Mincer, for the votes of confidence. Much obliged.

Right now I'm leaning toward the Seth Lover at the neck. At once both intrigued and anxious about unpotted.

Seems like a tough call between the SL and PG. On one hand, the PG seems to be perceived as brighter and that might pair nicely with the JD tele bridge sound (it's kinda bright!) but in the neck position of a tele (with maple fretboard, I may add) I wonder if it might be too bright. The SL is alternately described as having both a little presence roll-off and "airy" but also "warm" and "three dimensional" so I'm stumped on that, but they are so well regarded that I figure it's hard to go wrong with the original, great humbucker sound.

Both the SL neck and PG neck are comparable in output, and I expect the JD bridge to just a touch higher output with of course a more cutting eq profile, that about right?

Thanks again y'all!
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

I dig the mellower, richer sound of the Seth Lover, and unless you are playing with a ton of gain right in front of the amp, I wouldn't worry about the lack of wax. The fact that the Seth and the JD are sort of opposite is a bonus to me.
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?

If I were going to go hotter pickups - and open to the potential of a SC-size bucker at the bridge - anyone care to suggest a more rockin' pair? lil 59 bridge and a __________? Hot rail bridge and a _________?

Thanks!
 
Re: 72 Custom tele (neck HB, bridge SC) suggestions please?


+1

Those Telenator people seem to know what they are talking about - right down to the pot values and resistance tapers to recreate the real deal. Too bad that the full-on CuNiFe option costs as much as a genuine original FWR humbucker.

If you absolutely have to have the unique sound of an original Wide Range humbucker, this is the way to get it.

If you have never experienced the unique sound, you will not miss it by fitting another design under an over-sized cover.
 
Back
Top