Another vote for a PRS here, there are plenty of plain tops or solid colours that look classy without being too flash if that's what you're after.
I'd say an older Gibson Nighthawk. I have one and love it!
But there were few versions. Which exactly do you mean?
This. The description in the original post sounds exactly like my Custom 22 (aside from the quilted top, which my guitar has).PRS was designed to be a cross between a Les Paul and Strat...Problem is, then people complain it doesnt sound enough like a Les Paul or enough like a Strat, so you cant please everybody