Re: Amp repair
NOS caps, especially electrolytics, are generally a bad idea. They leak, grow bulges, bloat, dry out etc and that's how you get excess noise, tonal changes from drifting values, and ruined parts. Here's a personal example: I recently had to change the original coupling capacitors for the power valves on my silverface bassman because the bias on one V6 ran away, burnt out the tube, caused a short, and blew the mains fuse. When I put in a completely fresh power valve set, the same thing began to happen on the same valve slot (V6) so I knew something in the amp went bad. I mainly suspected the coupling capacitors, so I replaced those (and while I was at it I changed both the plate+screen grid resistors for extra precaution despite them checking out OK because I didn't want to ruin more any more valves) and the problem went away. Old capacitors in things like the tone stack aren't that big of a deal, but with the power section you want those capacitors to be reliable, which NOS capacitors generally aren't. In fact, you'd probably have better luck with old used capacitors instead of old unused capacitors - they have a shelf life of 5-10 years max and dry out quicker if they're left unused.
If the filter caps are old, replace them. I've had good results with F&T. They're good quality and not outrageously overpriced. A little maintenance goes a long way - the new parts are few and relatively inexpensive, but if the old caps completely fail a) the amp would sound bad as unwanted AC ripple is not being filtered out and b) you can damage the power supply aka the power transformer.
Guitar players are a strange bunch; "older" does not always equal better despite guitar forums-lore (just as "newer" doesn't always equal better).