Like with most OD pedals... I think that it can be big time dependent on the amplifier and speaker. My BE-OD sounds great into the plexi channel of my Smallbox, as well as into the clean channel of my Roland Cube 80XL. I still haven't tried the BE-OD into the clean channel of my Quickrod yet though. And I just got my new Fender 65 Deluxe Reverb Sweetwater edition amp today, so I'll be trying the BE-OD into that amp tonight. I also ordered a Fender Super Champ X2 FSR today (as a daily practice amp), so I'll be curious how the BE-OD sounds into that amp.
Btw... I loved my Carl Martin Plexitone into the plexi channel of my old Bogner XTC Classic (as well as a few other amps that I had at the time), but HATED the Plexitone into my 65 Fender TRRI. So it's just so dependant on amp and speaker choice. Same goes for my old Fulltone OCD. It KILLED into my Bogner Shiva and Marshall 2203X, but didn't do so great into other amps. That's why I've learned that there is no one-size-fits-all OD pedal, and that I should have several different pedals around that work with different amps. My Bogner Harlow kills on the Smallbox Plexi channel and I'm also curious as to how it fares into my new Fenders combos.
It's cool that the BE-OD didn't work for you. I'm over taking these things personally. We all hear things differently and want different things. But I would caution you to remember what I said above. Because it's entirely possible that you could try a BE-OD into a different amp and love it. I found the BE-OD running into my Smallbox and Cube 80XL to sound very much like my buddy's BE100 head. And he's seconded my findings.