Re: Basswood - Underrated?
I think there is a lot of variation in the basswood that is used for guitars. My old Ibanez RGs and JEMs (i only have my rootbeer JEM left FWIW) always seemed heavier than some of the new cheaper basswood guitars. Mine have always sounded good. Yes, it is a little soft, but with a finish it's not going to ding any easier than anything else. An oil finish, yeah, it will dent pretty easy. Mine all have had some version of the Ibanez Edge trem on them too, but I never noticed of the posts getting loose, I did have some of the old screw type floyd posts get really loose in an old ESP with an ash body, I had to drill and dowel that one.
It comes down to personal preference, I've had basswood, ash, alder, mahogany, and even hard maple bodied guitars and have never had a problem getting good usable tones out of them.