Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

Dark Order Lord

New member
Aside from Ola's video had anyone else made video's or sound clips comparing the two, preferably with a real tube amp, not kempers or other modeling sounds?????
 
Last edited:
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I was about to say I'd love to but none appeared on the used market yet.

Maybe the fact that the people who buy them are hogging them should tell me something?
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I was about to say I'd love to but none appeared on the used market yet.

Maybe the fact that the people who buy them are hogging them should tell me something?

I think you're right. I know I won't be selling my BW set unless I absolutely have to. ;)
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

musiciansfriend has also stopped giving out 15% off coupons now that they are sold. The outlook is bleak.
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I too find the Black Winter an intriguing pup. I would LOVE a Distotrtion vs BW clip...
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I too find the Black Winter an intriguing pup. I would LOVE a Distotrtion vs BW clip...

Let's bug Evan to get keith or someone playing through a marshall or something (I know keith is on tour with Conquering Dystopia). That JB comparison video was awesome, the one that compares the 3 different JB's....
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I have clips on my YouTube channel of both of those pickups. Same riff, same amp, same settings, but in different guitars unfortunately. Hopefully this gives you some idea of the differences. I did use an Avid Eleven Rack though…so I guess that doesn't fit your requirement of a real amp. I have the DI files if you would be interested in running them through your setup (and you have that ability).

Distortion: http://youtu.be/ind1z_d3kTI

Black Winter Dirty/Lead: http://youtu.be/9amVDr7ZjGE

Black Winter Clean: http://youtu.be/FyneJ5xGxXc
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I have a couple of DI sounds but here's the Black Winters through a Blues Jr. with nothing but a Vintage Rat distortion. It's in B Standard. The BJ isn't the best for high gain, so I hope you forgive. No post eq, compression or any other effects. It was recorded with a USB mic (Blue Yeti) so there's still some pops and cracks. The only editing was to add the explanation and cut out a few bad playing bits. Otherwise, untouched. Hope this helps.



Here it is with less gain. I tried to futz with the settings because getting enough gain for that nice chugging sound ends up sounding bassy and oversaturated, but if I have a more reasonable level of gain it loses some of that chug. So you have the above video and this one with less gain. Again I apologize for not being a better shredder. I got this so I could learn some songs by people like Amon Amarth.

 
Last edited:
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I have clips on my YouTube channel of both of those pickups. Same riff, same amp, same settings, but in different guitars unfortunately. Hopefully this gives you some idea of the differences. I did use an Avid Eleven Rack though…so I guess that doesn't fit your requirement of a real amp. I have the DI files if you would be interested in running them through your setup (and you have that ability).

Distortion: http://youtu.be/ind1z_d3kTI


Black Winter Dirty/Lead: http://youtu.be/9amVDr7ZjGE

Black Winter Clean: http://youtu.be/FyneJ5xGxXc

Flippin heck! That won me over in 2 seconds flat! The Black Winter is far superior to the DD!!!!!!
 
Re: Black Winter vs Duncan Distortion......

I agree. The Black Winter has a ton more clarity and sounds way better clean than the Distortion. What guitar are you considering the BW for?

BTW, I watched your other videos, and I'm glad to see the Black Winter blows the BKP Painkiller out of the water!!
 
Back
Top