Chistopher
malapterurus electricus tonewood instigator
Re: Bridge Humbuckers in the Neck Position
My quote was referring to bridge models in which the only difference between neck and bridge is a few more thousand winds on the bridge, such as the Jazz and '59 sets.
Under this theory, I tried an SH-5 Custom in the neck position of a 24-fret SG/LP-type guitar, the Dean Deceiver, and found it bland and overly hot.
I bought a used PRS SE Santana, 22-fret version, that had a Gibson 57 Classic+ in the neck position. It sounded OK but was slightly hot for my taste; I prefer a standard 57 in neck position.
Over time, I've grown to embrace the older way of thinking, which is "whatever works in a given position". DiMarzio sometimes markets pickups as being good for both neck and bridge positions. The 36th Anniversary PAF (non-bridge version) is especially good in both positions. I like "same PAF in both neck and bridge position" setups like Gibsons with 57 Classics.
I think bridge position pickups could work in neck position if you want "more" out of the core tone of the neck version. The immediate contender in my mind is the Jazz bridge pickup. I find the Jazz neck pickup good-sounding but a bit wimpy, so it would make sense to add a little more oomph.
My quote was referring to bridge models in which the only difference between neck and bridge is a few more thousand winds on the bridge, such as the Jazz and '59 sets.