Saw this the other day, pretty cool. Kinda gave me the idea, I have a huge bin of shredded cds and dvds, build a guitar shaped jig, mix the shred with epoxy and press into the jig to form the basic body of a guitar.
Probably wouldnt sound good, epoxied polycarbon probably isnt the best tone wood, but look really cool
Construction always matters.......scale length, neck attachment, body shape, material used for body + neck etc, etc They all play a greater or lesser role in shaping the final outcome.
Its just that some cannot grasp the complexity of the situation and try and dumb it down to either its wholly the pickups or its wholly the wood.
Wonderful stuff, very cool, but after watching the whole video, there's no way that neck pocket will last. The epoxy doesn't permeate the primary substrate -it encapsulates it -which cannot last forever. Hopefully the string tension isn't enough to unseat it over time.
There was some guy Tim Shay I think
That made gutairs from wooden pallets and hollow core doors or some such
They sounded like guitars
Some had more sustain
Some resonated better
All sounded like guitars