Re: Completely Bummed out with 70th Anniversary Jimi Fuzz
Silicon fuzz faces are consistent units generally. However - being a fuzz face they are unlike any other modern pedal - they have their own thing going on and pretty much will sound like ass unless you build your whole sound around it.
This is coming from a devoted fuzz face user.
Forget everything you know about dialing in your sounds and start again with new ears. Fuzz faces are so sensitive to everything you do. They are not simple plug and play pedals like bigmuffs, overdrives or any other jfet, mosfet, diode or buffered pedals. They are way more subtle than that.
My setup is similar to yours. I use a twin (clean of course) and use pedals for dirt. Actually, i only have one pedal in my chain and its a silicon fuzz face most of the time (that is, if its not a germanium one). It takes quite a while to get the sweet spot on the fuzz dial. Too low and everything starts sounding dark and muffled. Too high and its just a wall of splattery fuzz.
Try this:
Set your amp so you are getting a fat clean sound with your guitar knobs on 10.
Set your guitar volume on say 5 and switch on the fuzz. Turn the fuzz gain down until when you play softly there is no distortion in your signal - only a little grit when you dig in.
Set the fuzz volume level so that this "fuzz on" clean sound (gtr on 5ish) is roughly equal to your unaffected clean sound with your guitar volume on 10.
Dial in your amps eq so your "fuzz on" clean sound is fat and warm.
When you are ready, wind up the guitar volume to unleash various shades of fuzz from clean to wall of noise - try to avoid that last half knotch between 91/2 and 10 on your guitar dial because there is a big jump there.
You might find that getting the exact spot where everything balances and you have controllable fuzz on tap take a while. I dont belive in the "Set the fuzz on 10" school of thought because the coloration and sound of the fuzz changes at different spots on its dial and of course it is very much interactive with your guitar knobs.
Once you get the sweet spot - mark it with a sharpie to save time in the future.
I think your pedal is most likely a good example of a silicon fuzz, i think you are just finding that fuzz is a whole other world to regular pedals and are experiencing the usual state of shock mixed with the usual "these things suck" response. This initial shock you are experiencing is why fuzzes almost died out, but with time and patience i think you will find a lot of the really cool stuff that a fuzzface can offer.