Re: Does this seem like a complicated rig to you?
I play in a classic rock/blues/pop/country do-it-all cover band. I use one of my five Mesa amps--usually a Mark IV 112 EVM combo with a 112 EVM Theile cab under it. And for some gigs--I wind up taking as many as five guitars and a 5-string banjo!
I use a Furman Pedalboard loaded with the following pedals:
DOD FX10 Preamp
Boss CS-3 Compressor
Boss TU-2
Real Tube 901 overdrive (with a 12AU7 tube in lieu of a 12AX7)
Thomas Organ Crybaby
Boss CE-2 Chorus
Boss PH-1r Phasor
AND,....
I run a Rocktron Short Timer and a Line 6 Echo Park thru my Mark IV's footswitchable effects loop. These pedals are also on the Furman, and powered by the Furman's power supply. These are my newest pedals. Running them separately thru the EFX loop did complicate things a bit.
So, our rigs are fairly similar...don't you think? Your JSX is a fine amp, and capable of getting a wide variety of tones.
The trick to pedals is having hundreds of them--and using them RARELY!!! LOL! Seriously, I use the Real Tube for ONE song (preferring to use the Mesas' LEAD CHANNEL for most of my distortion.) I'll probably use my Phasor on four or five songs per night; and the chorus and the wah will get used about the same amount. The DOD Preamp and the Compressor are almost always on--the Preamp gives just a slight boost--the compressor actually is set more for limiting than as a sustainer. I use just a small amount of amp reverb (unless I crank it for a "surf" tune.) I do use the Short-Timer for several songs. The Echo Park is set for longer delays, but again--it's used for maybe four or five songs.
My rule is: "Effects that are over-used don't have much effect!" Yet, you'll hear guys that play EVERY SONG with their fav pedal, be it Wah, Chorus, Echo, etc. YUK!!!
So, no I don't think your rig is too complicated. You have a good selection of the most commonly used pedals. Used wisely, you should be able to re-create many popular tones--and at least capture the FLAVOR if not the exact tone.
Good luck!
Bill