GandLMan said:it really depends on your liking . . . me personally, for any blues gigs i would do, i would prefer a cranked fender tube and use my fulldrive to boost it. However, if I was to play any rock type stuff, Id be all over a cranked up marshall plexi, what kinda style do you play?
STRATDELUXER97 said:You pretty much still need a Marshall to get a Marshall tone,but yes,a great pedal through any great sounding tube amp is icing on the cake!
twoheadedboy said:I don't believe the part about needing a Marshall for marshall tone. I've heard killer marshall crunch out of modded Bassmans.
drew_half_empty said:with an open back 1x12, you will NOT achieve a good hard rock tone, it's just not possible
Satch1222 said:Does a cranked clean tube amp (Fender Hot Rod Deluxe for example) with an excellent distortion pedal sound better or equal to a regular Marshall, Mesa, etc.? Would it give you ample distortion and your own vibe because it's just plain different?
drew_half_empty said:with an open back 1x12, you will NOT achieve a good hard rock tone, it's just not possible
ericmeyer4 said:thats not true at all. will an open back fender sound like a marshall? maybe... probably not... but to say you CAN'T get a good hard rock tone out of a open back 1x12 is just closedminded.
people have gotten great hard rock tones out of small wattage open back 1x8 amps in the studio so why is in not possible with a open back 1x12?
drew_half_empty said:I assume you're reffering to weezer
the reason is; miking both sides of the amp, as well as doubling, if not tripling tracks, is all possible in the studio
live? well, maybe for some people, but around here, there are no sound guys, or even amp mics, so basically, you crank your amp & you go, and i used to own a hot rod deluxe, and yeah, not possible
FretFire said:I wasn't referring to any band actually, just a general statement. Also, the studio and a live performance are COMPLETELY different animals. I tend to fault the HRD's gain channel more than the cabinet design in that instance.
As far as using a PA vs. just cranking up, to me that boils down to science really. Guitar amps and cabs are extremely directional, so if you have a little combo amp up on stage (and in reality even if you use a 4x12") the people that are going to hear you the best are those right in front of your speakers. Everyone else will suffer an extreme loss of volume/dynamics/etc the farther off to the side they are. So of course you have to crank up in that scenario to be heard by everyone (at the expense of those right in front of the cab). I don't place the blame for "having to crank it" solely on the number of speakers or the wattage of the amp you use, there are many many factors at work.
drew_half_empty said:I assume you're reffering to weezer
the reason is; miking both sides of the amp, as well as doubling, if not tripling tracks, is all possible in the studio
live? well, maybe for some people, but around here, there are no sound guys, or even amp mics, so basically, you crank your amp & you go, and i used to own a hot rod deluxe, and yeah, not possible