You know what this means, don't you?
The Police had musical chemistry and personality clash tension. So did The Who. So did The Cream. Three of the most explosive three instrument plus vocals live acts of all time.
Oysterhead might be a bit leftfield for a 19 year old. I doubt that your "difficult" drummer would get it. When I was your age, the King Crimson album Discipline had recently been released. Half of my band understood it, the other half did not.