Guitars vs Amps

waltschwarzkopf

New member
Quick one: Would you rather have just one guitar and many amps OR just one amp and many guitars?

Bonus: Why?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I’ll start.

I used to be a one-guitar one-amp person. But, While I was looking for my ideal guitar, I had one amp and bought many guitars to try scales, construction, wood, pickups until I found the one. Now I’ve narrowed it down to three guitars, from which I may keep only one in the end. BUT, now I have three amps and one-two more coming to find my sound. In the end I may keep one guitar and one amp like I started. What about you?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

My first instinct was "one guitar, many amps", but then I realized that a good channel switcher would do most of what I like multiple amps for, whereas I can't (easily) have one guitar set up for both baritone and standard tuning.

So, one amp, many guitars ("many" being "2 or 3" tbh).
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

don't work...gotta have at least three guitars and two amps:
Strat type;
LP type;
Acoustic.
5E3 gigable;
5F1 recording.
If you had to meet the defined requirement...drop the 5F1 and mod(hate to do it) 5E3.
 
Last edited:
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I could easily get along with just one amp if it were my Spidervalve. Then have all the variety offered by my guitars.

Sent from my Alcatel_5044C using Tapatalk
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I could do one amp if I had to, either my JVM410H or maybe a Roadster.

There’s no way I could do one guitar. My most versatile instrument falls well short of the basics to make me happy.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I must say, I don't really like these sort of hypothetical questions, it's like asking what you would eat if you could only eat one thing ever again.

Sent from my Alcatel_5044C using Tapatalk
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I like having more amps. If you've kinda already bonded with one guitar and like the way it plays and the sounds it makes, you can just switch the amp/cabs/speakers/mics to get a wider (in fact, huge) pallet of sounds without changing a thing on your #1 guitar.
also a practical case with multiple amps and one guitar is for example a blues player who likes power tube breakup for his sound might have a champ for a small room and recording, a princeton for a bigger room, and a deluxe for etc. But the idea is he can get kinda the same tone but fit the amp to the gig.
Or you can pick fenders for country gigs and take the marshalls to rock gigs.

There are some amazing one trick pony amps out that kill for one sound, collect them all and change you sound completely without ever "cheating on" your #1 axe.

I used to feel like it's cool to have several guitars and still do but you can only play one guitar at a time, you can sure jumper, slave, and aby multiple amps. And having one guitar lets you really get to know that guitar so you had better really enjoy that thing enough to not want to switch.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

don't work...gotta have at least three guitars and two amps:
Strat type;
LP type;
Acoustic.
5E3 gigable;
5F1 recording.
If you had to meet the defined requirement...drop the 5F1 and mod(hate to do it) 5E3.

After a lot of amps I found in the 5e3 the perfect amp. I can do (blue note) jazz and blown up classic rock tones. I could definitely just have a 5e3 and several guitars. It records great as well IMHO.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I could deal with one of each, but don't have to. I'd go for more guitars, because I at least need 1 acoustic.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

More amps than guitars. Probably two or three guitars at minimum. It's all do to GAS...one of each would surely do if necessary, but it isn't! :D
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

Does Line 6 Helix count as one amp, multi-amp or no amp at all? :scratchch
 
Last edited:
Re: Guitars vs Amps

Definitely one amp and multiple guitars... pretty much what I’m already doing. One amp with pedals for getting different “amp-like” flavors is plenty, and if I want/need more sound I can always mic the amp into the PA.

I’m currently at 17 guitars and love them all for different reasons... the feels, the sounds, the different flavors or styles that each inspires me to play. I definitely have a number one, but for me playing each of my guitars is a real, unique, and personal experience. Amps to me are simply a means to an end, but guitars are deeply personal.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

I'd certainly say that about most of them, but I haven't tried the newer ones.

Truth be told, I’ve never played through one. There are several local bands that use them and I’ve yet to hear a good tone come out of one.
 
Re: Guitars vs Amps

Helix solves the one amp vs multiple amps issue IMO.

I just wish I could afford one!

Well... If you have audio interface I higly recommend trying Helix Native 15 day trial. (actually I'm using the native version and it's awesome)
 
Back
Top