Help me with my Frankenstrat

gypsy

New member
I've got all the parts together, except the body. I can't decide on which wood for this strat. I have a couple of very nice Fender custom shop alder bodies but I just never liked the tone of alder with a humbucker. It's too much hard midrange or something. I never get the sounds I want with them. Alder with single coils sounds much better to me. More balanced.


Last year I bought a used Nocaster. It's got that light swamp ash body and it ruined every other guitar I own. It's chunky, woody sounding and chimey all noticeable while playing unplugged, similar to my '58 Les Paul. Plugged in on the tele, I can play metal on this thing and it screams and kicks with aggression, then some nice slide blues sounds killer. I get compliments on the tone all the time, much more than my other strats. It's perfect. But it's a tele design. You may laugh, but it sounds very close to VH I tone. It's a little scooped, tight and in your face. I can do a very convincing early Halen tone with this tele!

But it's a tele design and I'm not sure swamp ash is for the strat.
I built a lightweight Warmoth swamp ash strat years ago and it sounded "tinky" like a banjo. The guitar had zero low end and was all toppy, I interchanged necks and nothing helped. Maybe I just had bad wood? I'd be afraid to try it again.

So I'm looking for some wood for my #1 strat. Building it, interchanging parts until I find the right combination that can give me a killer tone like the tele. What should I try? Basswood? Korina? Nothern ash?
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

If you're gonna put humbuckers in it, i say go with mahogany-or one of the hollow body warmoth designs would be nice and light.

Korina would also be nice.
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

if you are looking for less midrange, i wouldn't get mahogany, cause it pumps out that low midrange. (sometimes.)
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

You know I'm not exactly sure how to describe it. I know that when I play a guitar acoustically I can tell if it's got it (for me). I have two Fender relic strats which I've mixed around and one was modded for a humbucker. Both are two piece alder. Very nice wood and nitro finish. I would like to trade someone for an ash custom shop body. I don't really need two.

My tele just has that woody tone acoustically. That's the only way I can describe it. It's fat yet open. My '58 Les Paul is like that as well. But I have played other '58 historics Les Pauls that didn't do that. I'm wondering if it's just "special wood", and how the hell do I find a special piece for my strat project.

I never had a basswood strat. I did have an Ernie Ball and that had no tone acoustically, but plugged in, it sounded really good and that's what counts. I hear that's a characteristic of basswood. Pretty flat sounding, letting the pickups do the work. I dont know if that's what I want. I had Brian Moore which is a Mahogany type strat. It had a nice dark tone, but it didn't sound exceptional or anything. It actually sounded a little "tinky" acoustically. I don't know anything about Korina.
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

Thanks for the info gypsy :) . I was originally looking at an alder body to crunch out great humbucking tones, I guess that solves one question. I wasn't impressed with super strats I've played in the past, too midrangey and they really didn't have any low end definition or crunch. Swamp ash I've heard isn't as versatile as alder is. I suppose with any of those combinations there needs to be some sort of a sacrifice.
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

Mybe what you're hearing in your Tele is the difference between a hardtail, string thru body bridge and the trem system in your strat. BTW, I can get killer AC/DC style crunch from my Tele with a JD.
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

thanks for the help everyone. I don't know if it's the hard tail thing, as I've played some strats that had that full, acoustic tone as well. They had trems. Unfortunately I don't know what woods they were made of. It's probably ash or alder. I just want a real resonant acoustic toned body for a strat. I need to find a magic one. I'm soooo picky!!!!!!!!

beandip, those bodies/strats were pretty expensive since they were relics, but I would consider selling one or trading. If you wish PM me about it.
 
Re: Help me with my Frankenstrat

yeah, or it could be you just didnt find the right pickup for the body?
 
Back
Top