Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

jimmy_fowler

New member
Hey guys,

This will probably end up being a long and ranting post, and I'd be sooo grateful if you stayed with me and offered opinions hehe.

Background first: I'm an 18 year old English kid in need of tonal advice. I've been playing guitar for six years, and whilst am by no means amazing, I feel competent. I've been playing music of some variety or other since I was four or five, as well as studying it at school, so in terms of theory I'd like to think myself somewhat knowledgable. My problem is not the playing of guitar, but finding tone. Having only had one amp for five years I don't know how to find what I want and it's frustrating me. I think I have a good grasp of EQ but not of equipment itself. This is incredibly frustrating as I have intentions of becoming a record engineer eventually. Obviously this lack of knowledge won't help! I've just bought my first mixing desk so I can begin to learn the art of producing and engineering records, but am now realising my tone sucks and sounds rubbish when recorded!

On then, to the problem...

I just bought myself a very nice new guitar: a sunburst Fender Telecaster, fitted with a Seymour Duncan Hot Rails at the Bridge. It plays nicely and sounds cool. But I can't get good tone from my amp and things.

I have an old 100 watt Marshall Valvestate amplifer (VS-100) which was second hand when I bought it five years ago, and I think is slowly dying.

I also have a Line 6 POD 2.0, but it doesn't seem to help my tone much, and I think it sounds too processed and not "real" enough. I'm thinking of selling it. Thoughts?

I know people come on all the time and ask to sound like their favourite band. I know this is stupid, especially as I don't even like the tone of half of my favourite bands! But I feel I should list some of the bands whose tone I DO like, even if I am not their greatest fan.

I like the guitar tone on the following albums:

- "Bayside" - Bayside
- "Blink 182" - Blink 182
- "Stranger than Fiction" - Bad Religion
- "Good Mourning" - Alkaline Trio.

I hope this helps. I play in what is, essentially, a heavy-ish punk band with emo leanings. I hope this doesn't garner me too much of a slating! My songs sound something like this: the melody of Bad Religion/NOFX, etc, with the dark/goth sound of AFI/Alkaline Trio, with a touch of punky solo-ing, a la NOFX/Bad Religion again, with the heavy, palm-mute based fast rhythms of bands such as Metallica, Anthrax, and more recently, Trivium, and so on. I'd like to think despite the growing and saturated market of very lame emo-bands, I mix my influences to keep my sound fresh. I guess we sound most like a cross between Bayside and The Beautiful Mistake, perhaps with some Alkaline Trio and Taking Back Sunday thrown in.

When asking about tone, the problem is a lot of terms are thrown around on these boards that I can't "hear" in my head. I suppose for the music I play I want/need:

- Not too overdriven; I like to hear the tone, and I like clarity, as opposed to a lazy, loud mess that many pop-punk and emo bands have these days.

- Enough crunch so that palm-muting is clear but chunky, but not too metal-sounding and heavy-gained.

- Enough scream for solos, but again, punky-type solos, so not too high gain.

- I suppose is essence, the basic rundown is this; crunchy but not too high-gained, so I can play fast alternate-picking palm-mute on/off rhythms, with a clear, slightly raw punk tone and just enough wail for a good solo.


I'm not asking you to tell me the exact amp/pedal combo to go out and buy; an impossible task, and obviously personal preference plays a part... BUT... if you could suggest a small range, or even the terms/things I should look for, that would be awesome.

Price isn't really a problem but overall around £500-£600 would be ideal so I don't break the bank.
 
Last edited:
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

Some things some have suggested is:

Sell my POD 2.0 and sell/get rid of my Marshall VS-100, and get a Marshall TSL100 head and whatever cab, and perhaps an Ibanez TS9 Tube Screamer.

Any suggestions or comments are very welcome, especially as it's hard to find sound samples on the internet that give a clear indication.

Hopefully what I've said sets me apart from the newbies that come on and want to sound exactly like their favourite bands; I'm by no means a newbie, but struggle to turn what I hear into actual sounds, especially given my inexperience of lots of equipment. I also am searching for my own sound.

Thanks in advance for any and all assistance.

-James Fowler.
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

Did you get any ideas from the POD as to where you'd like to go with your sound?...or are you just looking to mold some clay?
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

Bit of both really, but on the Pod 2.0 the sound I liked best and I thought was one I might be able to mold was the Brit Hi Gain, which is a Marshall I believe so I think I like British amp sounds...
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

You know, this is almost one those "if you have to ask, I can't tell you" kind of questions. :)

I think if you can hear the tone you want in your head, then you should be able to figure out how to get it out of your guitar and amp eventually.

The Marshall Valvestate might have to go though. Solid State amps just don't have the tone of a great tube amp...they certainly don't "feel" like tube amps, and music is all about "feel".

Sounds like you have a nice guitar. Now get yourself a great tube amp and you should be able to develop your tone.

The truth is: your tone comes from YOU! It's in your soul and heart and you learn to shape it with your hands. It's not just the gear.

The great players sound just like themselves no matter what they're plugged into.

But I'd get rid of that Marshall Valvestate and get something with real glass bottle valves and no transistors.
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

Totally. Yes I know whatcha mean I have a sound in my head but my lack of knowledge means I don't have the first clue where to start hehe. The problem is there's not a guitar shop near, and I don't wanna be the kid that turns up and just plays everything hehe, which was I was looking for guidance.

Thanks for the help guys :-) I'll report back if I have more questions!
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

Try the POD in headpones for home use... you should come the sound you want very near!
I would rather get the DSL 50 or maybe a JCM900... but don't forget it's a tube amp and should be played loud!
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

I totally agree with Lew. You've got to ditch the valvestate and get a tubester. For what it's worth, I always push the Peavey Classic 30 because of its good sound-to-price ratio, though you do have to factor in replacing the crap stock speaker with a G12H30 or something like that. :usa2:
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

hellatone said:
I totally agree with Lew. You've got to ditch the valvestate and get a tubester. For what it's worth, I always push the Peavey Classic 30 because of its good sound-to-price ratio, though you do have to factor in replacing the crap stock speaker with a G12H30 or something like that. :usa2:

The Classic 30 is a very good sounding little amp. :) And bought used, they are a steal!
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

A good marshall is probably wat u want but dont be afraid to try brands like laney (they make the tony iommi head and VC30 which is a vox copy) do u like any old punk sound (a brash attitude type) because amps with EL84s, EL 34's (the laney's i mention) usually have a brashier sound then american amps but dont forget the circuit helps too.
 
Re: Help needed - tone: amp, pedals etc!

I think you really nailed it when you said the pod sounds too processed. Unless you are going to be recording sell it and buy a small tube amp so you can crank the volume past 5. I recommend a Fender. Make sure it has a good speaker. If not buy a Weber alnico. The Fender will give you an excellent clean tone to use as a base to build on and it will like your Telecaster.

Then buy two overdrive pedals and a fuzz. Use the first overdive pedal as a clean boost, the second to add crunch as needed, then the fuzz to push you over the top into sonic mayhem. You can then add delay, chorus pedals etc. to further enhance your tone as your budget allows.

Oh yeah one last thing, the search for tone never ends it is a lifelong pursuit like fishing or golf. Try to develop a network of friends that you can trade gear with.

Good Luck!

Lyon
 
Back
Top