I give up - whaddaya do?

Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

jtougas said:
I think the software development costs to pull it off would make it prohibitively expensive...
Click to expand...

You would want to do that with an in-house enthusiast. If you bid it out to a contractor you get non-working **** for a lot of money.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

Digital pedals would be easier - there's already sourcecode. Analog, and getting the emulation accurate? Not cheap. And that doesn't cover how you integrate it into a website. Flash development is going the way of the dodo, with HTML5 expanding.

On the other hand, they would also be able to convert it to VST plugin sales, sooo... *shrug*
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

jtougas said:
Digital pedals would be easier - there's already sourcecode. Analog, and getting the emulation accurate? Not cheap. And that doesn't cover how you integrate it into a website. Flash development is going the way of the dodo, with HTML5 expanding.

On the other hand, they would also be able to convert it to VST plugin sales, sooo... *shrug*
Click to expand...

I didn't mean emulation. I meant streaming through the actual pedal.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

uOpt said:
I didn't mean emulation. I meant streaming through the actual pedal.
Click to expand...

Ummm, yeah, no. Servers don't generally have audio cards in 'em, for one. Second, you'd have to have an individual I/O for each pedal/user combination (can't run multiple people through the same pedal at the same time). And if you're a reasonably large company with a reasonably active fan base, that adds up to a *LOT* of soundcards and power for pedals in an environment where power's already on a budget and your temperature is closely monitored. And daisy-chaining effects? F$%^ No. I wouldn't want to wire that matrix, much less program it.

At one point earlier today, this website had 1076 people visiting it. Say half of them wanted to audition a pedal... 500 people * 7 pedals, plus power... No. Nope, not gonna do it.

The VST concept is much more realistic, but would still eat your server cpu cycles - you'd need to have clusters dedicated for it.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

I don't think that writing a digital emulation would make sense either sound wise or business wise. That's instantly devaluing the physical product.

It might still be cheaper than accepting lots and lots of returns. You aren't comparing a pedal tryout to a page load. You are comparing a pedal tryout to mailing it out and maybe back.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

It's not devaluing the physical product, otherwise Universal Audio wouldn't be selling both the hardware and the emulation plugins. It's working to different market segments - the people that play the pedal on the floor in front of the amp will still do so, while the studio rats (like myself) will take that pedal emulation, and try it out on a drum track, a bass track, a vocal track, a keyboard track, and use it in ways we wouldn't otherwise be able to do as easily.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

Wait this vendor has the same product as digital plugin and as pedal?
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

We're working with hypotheticals here, dude, aren't we? ... (but yes, Universal Audio does have both physical hardware and digital emulations of their stuff)

I don't know of any manufacturer that does what you describe on pg 2 - letting you upload a sound clip, process it, and email it or a link back to you... the labor costs associated with it would be... yeah, no.
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

Did it start with Lazarus innocently asking to test out pedals without committing to take the new->used price hit?
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

uOpt said:
Did it start with Lazarus innocently asking to test out pedals without committing to take the new->used price hit?
Click to expand...

Not quite. It started with me not being totally satisfied with something I purchased. Most places will accept returns so that's not the issue. Since then I've decided to live with the fuzz I bought and adjust to it. I may keep shopping and hold on to this one too. It is part of the insanity.

In any case, it hasn't been given a fair chance on a guitar strung with month old 9s.
 
I give up - whaddaya do?

Ah. I didn't look at the Pharaoh - I assumed by the way you were talking about it that was more like a Russian Big Muff.

My faux pas...
 
Re: I give up - whaddaya do?

Lazarus1140 said:
I did read that review and upon rereading am surprised that the author would prefer more high end and more mid-scoop and that he would describe the mid-range as dark and creamy. That is not my experience ... a little darker and creamier would suit me just fine.
Click to expand...

This is the problem with most online reviews, personal preference. I try to be very neutral when I write up a pedal. Maybe it is not giving me a tone I would like but is it working as advertised and delivering something someone would find sonically pleasing. For example if a distortion is overly scooped and compressed I am not going to like it. However, an 80's guy might think it is the Holy Grail. I also try to keep in mind people are going to play a pedal with different guitars and cycle through a few axes and amps. Someone playing a pedal with a Tele and a HotRod is not going to have the same experience I am having with a Les Paul and a Marshall.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top