Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ozzynotwood
  • Start date Start date
O

ozzynotwood

Guest
I own 5 guitars. A Fender Telecaster, a Charvel Telecaster (that sounds like a strat), a Fender Jazzmaster, a Schecter Omen-6, and a Cort MR780FX acoustic.

They all sound completely different, not even the 2 Tele's sound anything like each other.

After looking at some pics of peoples guitars, I've seen alot of people buying the same guitar over and over again. Some peope have 5 les pauls, some have 5 strats. In some cases all the pickups are replaced with the one style of pickup in each guitar.

Other than investment, why do people buy guitars like this? I can understand have 2 guitars the same to serve as a backup for gigs, but up to 10 les pauls?

Educate me please.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

I have just walked around my flat (apartment) and counted 30 stringed instruments. Some are repairs. Most are mine. Why? Partly the same, "because I can" excuse as given by metlking, partly to gain access to specific sounds. e.g. I own a Seymourised Fender CIJ Jaguar specifically to make cheesy Surf and Spaghetti Western noises. Does a mean P. J. Harvey "I Think I'm A Mother" rhythm guitar tone too.

I have wasted far too much of my time, experimenting with pickups and body woods in an attempt to coax, say, a Les Paul sound out of a Strat or vice versa. This is the difficult way. The easy way is to buy a bleeping Les Paul or, in my case, a PRS Singlecut. Job done.

Another "reason" is Projectguitaritis. You upgrade the pickups and machineheads on a guitar. This leaves the original parts hanging around with nowhere to go. Should these be binned? Should they be sold off on Internet auction websites? Should they be fitted onto a battered, old SE Asian copy guitar that just floated into view on eBay? :naughty: More than once, I have purchased a pre-owned guitar because I know that it will match perfectly with some pickups in my parts drawer.

Then there is the "reason" that individual guitars feel (or "ride") differently from one another. This can influence the way that I play - hopefully, for the better. Double tracking a part with two different guitars can create a bigger overall sound. Just ask Jimmy Page.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

"The one that dies with the most guitars, WINS!!!"
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Cuz it can be a fun collector hobby as well?
Plenty of folks enjoy the guitar itself as art.
I know I do.
Also, even two "identical" guitars can feel/play/sound very different due to natural variations in the wood.
Ever date "identical" twins before?
They can be quite different indeed.
:)
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

At one stage I had 14 guitars and I never wanted any of them to be alike and I succeeded with the exception of having 2 USA Wolfgangs. My plan at the time was to take one of the necks off and have a luthier put an Ebony board on .... Alas the reccession hit and I'm down to 5 now anyway. All said and done, I do gig all of my gear and it has actually been good for me to have to sell guitars and amps as I have removed the problem of trying to decide what to take out. My playing has also improved (still not too good mind!) as I'm learning how to use what I have left to better effect and I've found I'm bonding much more with them. Still, guitars are my passion.... would I have rooms with walls filled with guitars of all shapes and sizes? Hell yeah if I had the money! I'm glad I still have a couple of nice guitars around, I have been humbled and appreciate what I have more than before.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

I have 15 les pauls, and there are no 2 guitars alike; different topwoods, different neckwoods, different pickups, nothing is alike. I only play les pauls, cause the look KILLER, and play lovely! (oh 10 LP's are warmoth LP's, 2 gibsons, and 3 crimson guitars-guitars of which 2 are under construction). I have them, because I can, and because I like the feel and vibe and looookkssssss
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Eh, I don't get it either, but that's just me. I've got 3 good electrics: 2 PRS McCarties and a Fender Strat. My Fender Strat is my go-to single coil electric, one of my McCarties is a go-to humbucking guitar and I'm either going to sell the other McCarty outright or put in some TV Jones pickups to give it a tone wildly different than the other two.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Another "reason" is Projectguitaritis. You upgrade the pickups and machineheads on a guitar. This leaves the original parts hanging around with nowhere to go. Should these be binned? Should they be sold off on Internet auction websites? Should they be fitted onto a battered, old SE Asian copy guitar that just floated into view on eBay? :naughty: More than once, I have purchased a pre-owned guitar because I know that it will match perfectly with some pickups in my parts drawer.

+1. If you love guitars, sometimes you buy them just to put different PU's and wirings in them. I think a number of us do it. It's normal, it's healthy.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Some peope have 5 les pauls, some have 5 strats...why do people buy guitars like this? I can understand have 2 guitars the same to serve as a backup for gigs, but up to 10 les pauls?

You sound like my wife. There's big name players that have collections of several thousand guitars, and you harp about guys with a dozen LP's? We're Americans. We're here to consume. It's our destiny. If the good Lord wanted us to lead simple, non-materialistic lives he'd have put us in another country. Loosen up. What do you, sit at a table & count your money every night?

With LP's, come on, you have Std's, Customs, Studios, double cutaways, Specials, Juniors, solid colors, flame tops, arch tops, flat tops. You can put in all kinds of PAF's, hot HB's, & P-90's. There's no shortage of wiring ideas, from basic coil cut & coil swap to the Jimmy Page 4 push-pull system. It's easy to come up with 5 or 10 very desirable LP variations. Some of us have to control ourselves to limit it to that.

Putting the same PU's in 10 guitars is weird. Obsessive. But putting different PU's in 10 of the same kind of guitar, now that makes sense. Are you following the logic here?
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

For some of us, the guitar provides both a hobby and an outlet for creative expression. It's the hobby aspect of it that leads to having more guitars than some folks would deem necessary.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Because I can..........

Allow me to elaborate: I love guitars! I love having many guitars. I regularly play guitars infront of people and I get paid (a little) to do so. I know what pickup works for me in a Les Paul. I know what pickup works for me in a Stratocaster. I want to sound a certain way (same ballpark) no matter what guitar I decide to take to the gig, I still sound like me anyway. I have no children. I work for a living. My bills are always paid on time. I don't buy garbage, almost every guitar I've sold I made money on. I have no other addictions or dependencies on any chemicals, though I do enjoy beer.

My Les Pauls all carry the same pickup but they all sound/feel different to me! Same with my collection of Strats!

.........Did I mention I love guitars?!?!?!? :arms:

Like I said in the "Show us your Strat" thread that probably prompted the OP....Anything worth doing is worth overdoing!
 
Last edited:
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

All of my guitars have a different pickup in them.. and they all are different colors. :D

<----
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

It´s all about options. Sometimes you want thick and crunchy, sometimes you want bright and airy, sometimes ....

Same with food. I love spaghetti, and I love steak, but I don`t want to have to eat either every day for the rest of my life.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

To add to Blueman335's and MikeS's EXCELLENTLY worded points. :fing2:

The same concept applies with many Fenders. Having 4 or 5 stratocasters enables the same concept, but in many cases to an even greater extent. One can own a completely bone-stock '54 Strat, low-power S-S-S, vintage trem, bakelite-based plastics, etc., and yet also own a '57 with 500k pots, three duncan Hotrails, a 5-way switch, 3 ply-guard, callaham trem, etc. At the same time, one can own many, MANY modern H-S-H routed strats and be left with a near infinite level of pickup possibilities ranging from H-S-H with coil-splits, blender pots (neck and bridge pots), S-1 switches to convert parallel wiring to series wiring, mini-toggles, etc. A person with 5 strats can not only have 5 completely different pickup configurations / wiring configurations / bridge configurations, etc., but can EASILY mix and match parts to various strats (so long as the screwholes line up) with a small set of screwdrivers and a soldering iron. This interchangeability and variations that exist in parts, even within the production line (Remember, Fenders were made to be easy to maintain / replace parts on) allowed for the creation of legendary guitars such as Blackie, and in the case of the Charvel "Hot-Rod" copies, Frankenstein (Which EVH stated was him picking out a body and a neck labelled "second" on the assumption that "second" meant they were "second in line to be used" as opposed to "some sort of flaw".

However, back on topic, the reason that most people own 5 Les Pauls, or 5 Strats, or 5 Whatevers is because it makes that interchangeability that much easier. Imagine being at a set with one stratocaster and seven pickguards. You'd have to not only be very quick with a soldering gun, but you'd have to be able to know which pickguard produces what tone within that particular guitar. Having multiple guitars, even if the guitars are the same line / species... for example, having several american deluxes, one with SCNs and stock wiring, one H-S-S vintage superstrat, one vintage S-S-S, and one modern H-S-H. Having the same body style combined with different pickguards means that its owner could swap guitars mid-set with a minimum of lost time (this is why SRV had #1, Lenny, etc., in the event he broke a string or a guitar got damaged, he could swap mid-set, or even mid-song. Furthering this, people have multiple guitars (this is true in particular with strats) because screws can strip out the wood of a guitar over time, and if too many screwholes are stripped, this can compromise the integrity of the Pickguard / Body relationship. Hence, multiple guitars for multiple pickguard wirings to minimize undue unscrewing.

As for MikeS's point. There's a reason why the Stratocaster is copied. It was, at least body-wise, a revolutionary design that shared its name with the contemporary "super-plane" of its day, the B-52 stratofortress. It was the first to have a dual-horned design for easy upper-fret access, and the slightly-offset contours, combined with the aesthetics of simplicity with a minimum of over-the-top body shaping, makes it an icon and a study in industrial design. It's a work of functional, completely usable art, and even within the name "stratocaster", there are variations on the theme, some traditional (50s to 60s evolutions with the body contours, neck shapes, etc.), some not so traditional (LSR nut use, the HM strat's black / graffiti / 8-bit NES graphic), some a nod to the competition (HSS strats), and even special runs that are intended as more obscure variations. The beauty of this art is that owning more than one provides not only different sonic opportunities (comparing a SCN'd AmDlx to an original '57 will yield VERY different sonic, and physical properties that owe to about 50 years of technological evolutions in electric guitars, while acknowledging the greatness of the original design), as well as a perspective on what was considered ideal by players or big business, dependent on what era of Fender we're looking at. These eras bring different building ideologies, (contoured heels, 4-bolts, 3-bolts) as well as what sounds were "the flavors of the day"... particulary 50s and 60s strats, before hotrod companies (Duncan, DMZ) began to market hot-rodded / aftermarket pickups to help cross-breed the "big two" into each other's sounds. So yes, the electric guitar is an artform, as well as a story-teller to what sort of sound was "en vogue" among musicians, and each decade, or even year tells a story as to the state of musicianship and corporatism in the United States, and later on, internationally.

Just my .02

Jason
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

While I would LOVE a tricked out 1957 Chevy Nomad or '57 Sedan Delivery, I find owning 61 guitars and 4 basses more "My Thing". 20 are Explorer shaped. It's just me. :dunno: :cool2: :7:

I blame my guitar heroes Rick Neilsen, Joe Perry, and Brad Whitford. They are all gear hoes.
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

^ Why not combine both with one of those Eighties "tailfin" guitars?
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

... We're Americans. We're here to consume. It's our destiny. If the good Lord wanted us to lead simple, non-materialistic lives he'd have put us in another country. Loosen up. What do you, sit at a table & count your money every night? ...

I know what you´re trying to say, but this is definitely NOT the way I would have said it?

Do French, British, German, Spanish, Italian, Austrian, Belgian, Swiss, Finnish, Swedish, Norwegian, Portugese, Russian, Israeli, Indian, Japanese, Brazilian, Mexican, Canadian, Australian, .... People have different destinies? Will they not experience the same apocalypse as everyone else? Do you know something that we all need to? :eek13:

Again, I know what you´re trying to say, but the way your statement is worded plays right into the hands of anti-american sentiment the world over by by placing our citizens on a pedestal and implying that our egotistical, materialistic wants are more important than other´s basic needs... And then you even make the "Bush Mistake" and declare that God wants it that way... ;)

BTW, the amish are a perfect counter-example to your statements. No materialism, no excess, but they´re still americans, and they most definitely also believe that they´re living as god intended.... So at least one of those viewpoints has to be wrong if god`s will is truly universal. ;)
 
Last edited:
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

My Love for the '57 tailfin is covered with the Explorer shape.

My '05 Dean Bass

1bb5.jpg
 
Re: Is there something I dont get about owning many guitars?

Do French, British, German, Spanish, Italian, Austrian, Belgian, Swiss, Finnish, Swedish, Norwegian, Portugese, Russian, Israeli, Indian, Japanese, Brazilian, Mexican, Canadian, Australian, .... People have different destinies? :eek13:

Same everywhere. Death and taxes.
 
Back
Top