What about a Seth Lover? I found it soft and clear at the same time.
Spent some time really working with the height today and it's better. May try the A2 swap. Guess the Kiesel Beryllium's and the SNS set have spoiled me as both have an almost acoustic quality with the right touch and amp clean that the Jazz just doesn't have. Duncan is really missing a large market IMO by not marketing the SNS set to the modern Worship crowd. Lamabatone and Suhr with the Thornbucker set are making a killing in that market. Have owned the Thornbuckers and played the Lambatone Cremas enought to know I prefer the SNS set to both.
I actually think you're being too picky.
For what you're playing, does it really matter that much?
The jazzN can be tweaked amazingly well. Use an alnicoIV to smooth out the high end and attenuate the low end a bit, and fill up the midrange. Use an A2 to make it sweet, bit creamy, flowing and fluid, with soft low end and boosted midrange. Give an A3 for a more open feel and organic tone, tighten up the low end a bit but keep the sweetness of the A2.
Install shorter poles to make it even more open sounding, clearer, brighter.
THEN move to different pickups.
Well considering the fact that I get called by a number of pretty well known worship artist to play events it's matters much! Matters as much for me as tone does for any other working player in any style. I have other guitars with Pickup set ups that are working for me but this one isn't.
Example a one off event with some of the local guys here playing my 17 Kiesel DC with a pair of Marks Singles and a Beryllium bridge. No real band practice charts and I got the call to play guitar.
What I meant was that your guitar is so much in the background that it can't even be heard most of the time (by anyone other than you).
Yes, a personal quest for you to find the tone that you like. I get that. But you say you have other guitars that are essentially "perfect" that you are comparing this one to. So, use the other guitars that have that great tone you love, in your worship groups. Why do you want this one to sound like those? Is it that this guitar has the feel that you like? The neck that suits you best? That you like playing this guitar a bit more than the others so you want this one to be your number one guitar with the tone you want? If so, then take the pups that you love out of your other guitars and put them in this guitar then you'll have your perfect guitar. Sell the others or the pups that you don't like.
When I played lead in my last covers group (actually all the groups I ever played in except one), my guitar was in the fore front and was heard and had to have the right sound for any particular song. But I had several guitars with totally different set-ups so I could pick the one that gave me the sound I needed...the sound the audience could hear and was expecting (so it would sound like the original artists). But if I just played in the background, it didn't much matter what guitar I played.
This is a funny thing with tone chasing - having multiple guitars with different sounds but swapping parts so they sound the same.
What I meant was that your guitar is so much in the background that it can't even be heard most of the time (by anyone other than you).
Yes, a personal quest for you to find the tone that you like. I get that. But you say you have other guitars that are essentially "perfect" that you are comparing this one to. So, use the other guitars that have that great tone you love, in your worship groups. Why do you want this one to sound like those? Is it that this guitar has the feel that you like? The neck that suits you best? That you like playing this guitar a bit more than the others so you want this one to be your number one guitar with the tone you want? If so, then take the pups that you love out of your other guitars and put them in this guitar then you'll have your perfect guitar. Sell the others or the pups that you don't like.
When I played lead in my last covers group (actually all the groups I ever played in except one), my guitar was in the fore front and was heard and had to have the right sound for any particular song. But I had several guitars with totally different set-ups so I could pick the one that gave me the sound I needed...the sound the audience could hear and was expecting (so it would sound like the original artists). But if I just played in the background, it didn't much matter what guitar I played.
I think for some it isn't so much about making them sound the same as about getting them into the same ballpark output-wise, so you don't need to redial your rig for each guitar. That's how it was for me at least: when changing guitars live, there just isn't time for resetting.
I value the individual tone & character of different guitars - otherwise, why switch?
Still, most of my working axes are set up to use the same amp & effects settings.
When I was gigging constantly (simple rig by today's standards - no presets) it had to work that way.
Sure, some instruments are always going to be too dissimilar. And these days I'm often using just one guitar.
But I've stuck with the habit. It can be useful to have a palette of different voices all within a similar output range.
I say, get an A4 and A2, and keep each in for a week or 2 to decide which one.
I'd try the A2 first. It'll be an A2P which sounds like what you're after. If that is too smooth and creamy but it took you in the right direction (but just a little too far) then try the A4. I personally don't think that the A2 will take you too far, however.