Well one thing I've really figured out in this process is that I really don't like Tubescreamer clones. The gain on my pedalboard right now is a Soulfood set as a boost into a cheap 808 clone that just isn't doing it for me. All of the tubescreamer's I've tried just sound kind of.. mushy to me, so I definitely want something a little tighter than that. I am looking for something fairly big sounding that is fairly coloured sounding. I mean the type of thing where I can set my amp clean and use it as my sole dirt, and something which I can boost with the Soul Food to send it into huge fat screaming leads.
I'm looking into a preamp, more or less, so that I can just use my amp for it's clean headroom and for a clean tone. Medium-High-ish gain. Realistically, the highest gain stuff I play with one of the groups I play with is Pink Floyd stuff and a Hendrix tune now and again. My main band we do some original soul and bluesish tunes, combined with some ambient and instrumental jams. When I write it out like this it almost makes me think a muff-alike would be a better bet for me.