So, I wanted to report back on what I did etc….my guitar is a very bright semi hollow body - D’angelico Kurt Rosenwinkle dig model. Maple + spruce top. It had a very cheap plastic nut and I upgraded it to a bone nut. Predictably, that actually increased how bright it was. I swapped out the A5’s for A2’s and put the covers back on. That really helped take the edge off and warm the tone up. But it was still a tad bright for my tastes.
changed the pots to 250k CTS with .047 caps - that was exactly what the guitar needed. The tone is now very evened out and very full and rich with ringing second order harmonics. A very lush sounding tone now. Does jazz and blues extremely well She’s a tone monster now.
I think If it didn’t have a spruce top I wouldn’t have needed to go with 250k pots. It’s a bit unconventional for HBs I know but that switch really allowed the tone to balance out and just sing now
thanks everyone for your input and help!