Re: Match for Alternative-8 in Hellraiser C-1
Either pickup would match up with the Alt 8 fairly well and are very close in output to each other, but I'd probably recommend the '59 more out of those two choices.
Is this a metal monster? Are you playing leads/solos on the neck position or mostly chords and rhythms? Emphasis on clean tones or mostly playing with gain? What do you want the pickup to do?
Personally, I would probably opt for something like the Jazz for a balance of nice cleans with clarity under gain.
Alternatively, the SH-6n Distortion Neck model has more drive than most neck pickups, but still has lots of clarity and good articulation for being so hot. If you want a lush and warm neck tone in the same family as the 59/PGn, the SH-12 Screamin' Demon is another pickup that would match up to the Alt 8 well.