Re: Mesa Boogie Stiletto help...please read!
BOOGIE BILL has some great helpful advice. I do like Mesa products, and have owned a few.
Sorry to still have to tell you - A MARSHALL IS A MARSHALL. (wow do I sound like an existentialist here?)
A maverick may get "plexi" like sounds per se. So can a Heartbreaker, a Lone Star, and so many amps. I love Mesas for reliability, loud sweet tone, and versatility.
I do NOT like several Mesa models for the fact the EQ is not a simple little curve. You need a manual to set a mesa. The Maverick is solid, I am looking into one. The Blue Angel is great for a poor man's matchless. With mesas you cannot always dial the EQ to be or react like a Marshall bc guess what?? It's a MESA! The main bother to me, is on a dark stage, and in pressure situations - many Mesas require precise tweaking (mark 4 comes to mind) to get your tone. I CANNOT sit with a manual when I am on stage. I need to know that I can just turn the presence knob or treble, in other words, something simple to fix the EQ.
The one thing Mesa nailed is lower volume tube distortion with the option to get louder than hell with a little turn of the knob. I also like the use of tube rectifiers (makes for nice soft sag in recordings [or live]), the models like the Nomad and Dual Rec have great footswitching, and I LOVE that they incl a solo vol boost function on many models.
Just remember, when Mesa says an amp is a "British" sound - what do they mean? Hiwatt? Selmer? Vox? or hmmmmmmm MARSHALL?
I have played Buddas, Riveras, Marshalls, Mesas, Bogners, Roccafortes - god we can go on forever. I have A/B'd severeal of these. They are ALL good! However, if you want MARSHALL - sorry, bud, get a Marshall. I too have tried to fool myself.
The main beauty of a MARSHALL is how well they take pedals. They are easy as pie to mod, they really respond to volume and tone control changes.
If you want an amazing Marshall clone - Budda will tear up any of the vox/marshall hybrids with a great clean. Matchless will do this with less versatility and more classic tone. Rocco's will peel paint off the wall. Lastly, the Bogner Shiva is the sweetest non-MArshall I ahve ever heard. Remember, Mesa loves the fatness of their design in the lower mids. That EQ gives you a "mesa" flavor, no matter the "British" sound they are trying to give you.
Think about it this way, Dimarzio and SD have different tones, no? Both can make a classic PAF or high gain pickup and it will sound different. C'mon, we are ON an SD forum for crying out loud! Obviously there is a difference! Otherwise we would all buy Dimarzio.
And umm if tone was SOLELY in your fingers, there wouldnt be so many freakin' amps and guitars and tubes, strings, batteries, etc etc etc out there. C'mon even batteries matter (and no I didnt just get that from EJ, but someone just as talented). If that was altogether true, I wouldnt feel a Les Paul gives me a different feel altogether from a Strat. You will always sound like you, but feel and tone affect how you play (BTW a guy with hair crazier than mine named uhhh Slash feels the same way, as does some clown named Jeff Beck, and this hack named Jimmy Page)