Re: Metal tone test - opinions?
^ A problem with putting the mic close to get more "grind" is your essentially doing to the guitar amp what sh*tty vocalists do when they cup the mic (but what mic you are actually using is also an important factor). By doing that you're sacrificing clarity for more unneeded gain (especially when recording, you really do not need a lot of gain) that would boost every frequency quite a bit, making it sound overall like a garbled mess. In fact, you will get more clarity and capture the sound you have in person much better if you back the mic away a little, and let the mic capture sound from all speakers blended together. It would also be a good idea to use a microphone with a larger spread to capture sound. Jimmy Page utilizing this technique quite a bit, and he said the space made the overall sound bigger.
What makes this so bad though, is people will say "oh it can be fixed at the mixing board". Whoever says that, keep them as far away from the mixing board as possible. The recording will only sound as good as the actual recording itself allows. Doing a sh*tty recording and then trying to improve it is not going to work.
On the video, if you skip to 3:12, you can hear how the microphone is WAAAAYYYY too close to the speaker, and it gets that "cupped" sound that sounds so terrible. The Night Train amps are actually bright and clear with gain, but the mic placement ruins all of that. Epiphone stock pickups don't help either but they aren't as important in this case.