And I would totally agree if I was going purely on feel. At least on the scale lenght. I like the feel of a 25.5" scale lenght way better for fast palm-muting.
But I do prefer the feel of a Tune-O. I like the fact that they're raised slightly off the body. However, I'm not one of those guys who can't adapt to a low-profile bridge. I mean, after all, I also have an Esquire. But to be completely honest, I like the simplicity of having just two points to adjust the action on a Tune-O.
I do like a thinner neck and bigger frets, but I do think big part of the tone of a Les Paul is in the thick clunky body and the scale lenght. I find the more you lenghten the scale, the more Fendery almost twangy rather than Gibson growly guitars start sounding.
Don't get me wrong. I do like a good Super Strat. I wouldn't mind adding one to my collection. I used to have a Rob Scallon Chapman. Great guitar! But not very Les Paul-sounding.