Need help choosing an amp!

fenderguy12

New member
I think its finally time for me to trade in my vox vt30 and upgrade to an all tube amp. The problem is i have no idea where to start. I was sorta thinking I should get a nice clean amp and just use my multi effects pedal for the distortion. My main concern with that is i dont know how that would sound compared to an amp made for distortion. So could you guys help me out with that and reccomend me some amps. Also I would like to stay within 600$ and under 50 watts. I was looking at the jet city amps, vox ac15c1, and the fender hot rod deluxe, so let me know what you think about those.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I've been looking at similar stuff and I've decided on the AC15C1...I like the Hot Rod Deluxe well enough but it's way too loud for me right now, and I kind of like the AC15 tone a bit better too. I really liked the Deluxe Reverb Reissue but it's a bit more $, and I think I'm still a bit more into the Vox tone. Would love to have both. :)
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

Used or new? Recommend trying out a Marshall DSL, Carvin Legacy series I, VOX AC15, Laney, etc.

An amps tube disortion is far more fulfilling than a stomp box. Stomp boxes can't compete with a good tube break up. The Legacy and the VOX both have good cleans. The Legacy has both a great clean and a rock solid od tone. The DSL has a useable clean, but a really good crunch.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

digital effect distortion will sound like ass and defeat the purpose of getting a nice tube amp. There really is no comparison to speak of. Once you try a true valve sound you will wonder why you used a modelling/digital set up ever.
anyway....for your budget its an easy choice...fender hot rod deluxe....a nice clean channel, reverb, and a two stage dirty channel mean you wont need a crappy digital fx unit.
Re: the "too loud" thing...its really just the clean channel volume pot taper that makes it seem so loud.
However the other really good option out there apart from the vox is the peavey classic 30...really nice overdrive tone and a little cheaper than a fender (so you can afford a really sexy speaker as well).....
if your budget stretches to it...all 3 amps benefit from a speaker upgrade and will give you seriously sexy tones....food for thought....
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

What do you want to play?

Blues? Rock? Metal?

The first thing I would recommend is to go to a Guitar Center or something similar and sit down with a guitar and play through a bunch of different amps. that will give you a better idea of what is out there and what type of sound you can get. If you already have the Valvetronics; you may want to look at the Vox line or Orange. very different sounds, but both are excellent. The Vox AC30 is a great and I do mean great sounding amp, but they are loud so you have to consider how you will be using it also.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I just picked up an OCD and its a very good pedal. It's got a creamy and full and juicy sound to it with quite a bit of gain. Fulltone pedals come highly regarded as many will tell you. I've always used a pedal in conjunction with the amp's distortion to get my tone and they work great.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

A Hot Rod Deluxe, although loud as hell when cranked, sounds great without a pedal for cleans and the dirt channel is actually better than many people will tell you.
For something a lil warmer and more british, get a Haze 40.

If you want something a lil warmer at lower volumes, try an ac15 for straight vox-y stuff, a night train if you wanna get into slightly marshall-ish territory, a Class 5 for straight up marshall stuff with no frills, a Pro Jr if you like fender tones with no frills, or a tweaker if you want some of everything.

Add a pedal (even a cheap DS-1 would work) for more gain and there you go, almost all bases covered with any one of those amps.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I play things like zeppelin acdc Evh ozzy and metallica. From what you guys are saying and based on what I play I think it would be better to just forget the whole clean thing because from what you guys are telling me it wont sound as good. Tell me if im wrong there. But anyway Ive looked at the dsl a while ago and I really like it but i think it would be too loud. Is there anything out there comparable to it just lower watts? If not just reccomend me some other amps.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

Bogner Alchemist new is a bit more than you want to spend, but you can find them used for around $550. Absolutely gorgeous clean and crunch sounds, 3 different reverbs to die for, and 3 different delays which are warm and pleasant. 40/20 watts 6L6 power.

This amp can get very loud when you want it to, but it sounds amazing even at very soft levels.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

digital effect distortion will sound like ass and defeat the purpose of getting a nice tube amp.
i agree. from what i've heard of those solid-state voxs (which has all been really good), i would think the OP's going to need to plug straight into a nice little valve combo to appreciate the step up.
however, not all distortion units have to be digital modelling things; check out the blackstar HT boxes, for example.

i was originally thinking of the ac15cc1 with a greenback on account of the tremolo, but everyone loves the HRD.
if a used peavey turned up significantly cheaper than the above 2, i'd totally check it out.

EDIT - i only didn't say night train because you won't have a quick footswitching-type option to get between dirt and chime.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I play things like zeppelin acdc Evh ozzy and metallica. From what you guys are saying and based on what I play I think it would be better to just forget the whole clean thing because from what you guys are telling me it wont sound as good. Tell me if im wrong there. But anyway Ive looked at the dsl a while ago and I really like it but i think it would be too loud. Is there anything out there comparable to it just lower watts? If not just reccomend me some other amps.
Zep=marshall
ACDC=marshall
EVH=marshall
Ozzy=marshall
Metallica=marshall
all these bands and players at one time or another have defined their sound with marshalls. Sure eddie had a signature peavey model and ozzy has had various guitarists using various gear...but the basic tonal recipie for all these acts you mentioned is the sound of a marshall.

From that info id say look no further than a DSL....perfect for heavy rock styles and a really great crunchy distortion sound. You can get it in a 40watt 1x12 combo if you want small(ish).

Such an amp really is not too loud if you are standing next to a drummer and bassist. The big difference between a 40w amp to a 5w amp is not so much volume, but a bigger bottom end - which is always a good thing. Wattage is not the real indicator of an amps volume....its really more an idicator of headroom (especially bass frequencies). The big difference in volume comes from the efficiency of a given speaker and also it eq curve because our ears are more sensetive to certain frequencies. Speaker size follows a similar vibe....so some 8 inch speakers can sound like its cutting your head off and a 12 can sound soft and warm. Bear in mind that a 4x12 will not necassarily seem loderr than a 1x12 due to the the fact that the 4 speakers are sharing the load rather than multiplying it. As a result you get more speaker headroom. The other thing to take into account is the fact that most 4x12s are closed back whereas most 1x12 combos are open back. Closed back cabs give a nominal 6db increase in bass frequency response.
So you can practice and gig with a 1x12 easily and a 40w amp will be powerful enough to drive bigger cabinets in the future if the need arises.

Modern amps like the dsl etc can get plenty dirty just by using the preamp section whereas amps of old needed to be cranked to get the power tubes saturating. Now a dsl still has the same power section of the old vintage jcms and plexis so it will sound better and fatter the more you wind up the master volume....but with the extra versatility of the modern preamps you can get a pretty good sound at more manageable levels also.

Re; dirt pedals....the dsl doesnt really need any per se....but if you want an even dirtier sound at lower volumes for practice then theres heaps of great ones for cheap (boss sd1 comes to mind or even the ds1). Even the cheapest analog stomp box will most likely eat your digital distortion for breakfast when paired with a nice amp. The other advantage of a pedal like an sd1 is that it will blend with your amps natural tube sound and take you to another level in terms of gain. this is also due to the fact that you can boost the level enough that you are making your preamp tubes distort further. Of course as you turn up the master volume on your amp...the extra gain cascades down thru to the power tubes also. Digital pedals are designed to create all their own dirt on their own and really dont go particularly well with a tube guitar amp in most cases.

So...a dsl with perhaps a nice (optional) od pedal and you have plenty of wicked, rich, responsive and organic sounds at your fingertips...
 
Last edited:
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

Solid amps: fender hot rod deluxe/deville (specially the new improved versions), supersonic 22 combo, Marshall DSL, Bogner Alchemist, Hughes and kettner (most models have worked out nicely for me), vox ac30/15 and variants...


run away from ANY amp line 6. i know we're talking about tubes and stuff but... you can never read this enough times, trust me: line 6 works int he studio, not on the stage.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

digital effect distortion will sound like ass and defeat the purpose of getting a nice tube amp. There really is no comparison to speak of. Once you try a true valve sound you will wonder why you used a modelling/digital set up ever.
.

%1000 true. I must say that certain classic distortion pedals really roar through a good tube amp. My JCM 800 was a beast that gave me monumental rock tone, but my hot rod deluxe got really angry whenever I plugged my DS-1 or DS-2 into it. the tube amp actually made the pedals sound better.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I think what some of you are trying to tell me is that a tube amp with a multi effects pedal distortion will sound bad but a normal distortion pedal would be fine? If thats the case that would work out great because I have a boss os-2.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

if you like the vox sound for cleans, stick with that. you can always add pedals for overdrive, etc. but the cleans are what distinguish the amp.

vox, marshall, peavy and fender have different sounding cleans.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I'm a former DSL owner. I liked the DSL but it was too loud for my apartment. If you can turn it up to 3 or higher it's awesome as hell.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

I'm a former DSL owner. I liked the DSL but it was too loud for my apartment. If you can turn it up to 3 or higher it's awesome as hell.

Hey man, when did you sell the DSL? I'm starting to re-like it again. I swear I have a love affair with it.
 
Re: Need help choosing an amp!

run away from ANY amp line 6. i know we're talking about tubes and stuff but... you can never read this enough times, trust me: line 6 works int he studio, not on the stage.

I almost agree with you. I REALLY hate any of the Spider amps...in the studio OR on stage. But I have a Flextone lll XL 212 that not only sounds good in the studio, but sounds even better on the stage. If you know how to use it, it works and sounds great.

My favorite amp so far, however, is my Bogner. Yes I know that there is the connection of the Alchemist with Line 6, but this amp is truly fantastic (except for the cooling thing going on and I'm picking up a fan for it today which will totally fix it). It IS, in fact, a Bogner amp with Line 6 effects (which just happen to be wonderful, by the way).
 
Back
Top