Re: New Epiphone Les Paul Standard coming my way
I just took a blind listening test on YouTube. A guy played both a Gibson Les Paul Standard and an Epiphone Les Paul Standard. I listened closely to both, not knowing which he was playing. Both guitars sounded extremely similar. After he got done playing the first one I thought to myself, "sounds good just like a Les Paul". Then I got to hear the second one. The second one sounded very much like the first one, but it had a more raspy tone. A little more bright and clangy. I thought "I'll say that's the Epiphone cuz we're taught to believe that Epiphones don't sound as full or as good as the genuine Gibson.
I was wrong.
Turns out the second guitar which sounded a little more clangy and raspy and perhaps not as full was the genuine Gibson!
The Epiphone had a better tone. Or at least to my ears it sounded more like a Les Paul should.
Something I've determined is that YouTube demos are nearly worthless for comparing things like pickups, or the sound of two different, but nearly identical guitars/guitar parts/guitar setups in general. I was in the process of making some pickup demo videos, and while editing them it occurred to me that even though I had played all the combinations clean and overdriven, and that the audio was decent quality, it didn't tell a fraction of the story for any of the pickups I was demo'ing. I think the reason is because
1) you're hearing the guitar, but you're not the one interacting. You know the output, but have no idea what the input is. The Gibson might have sounded raspy because of how it was or wasn't being played. Raspy is often a good sound, IMO.
2) even if you're the one playing the guitar, it can take a while to get a complete-ish impression of a pickups, or the guitar in general. For example, you could be playing rock on two different guitars, and think they're functionally alike, and then switch to playing country riffs, and then suddenly it's as though they have nothing in common any more, because the different styles demand you do different things that bring out different weak or strong spots in the pickups, or the entire guitar.
A lot of people think the poly necks on the Epi's feel cheap, and I don't have any trouble seeing where they are coming from. I think the best thing to do is play a Gibson and Epi back to back and decide if the Epi is a wannabe Gibson in your opinion, or a fully ideal instrument on it's own. Even though Gibsons are expensive, as people have pointed out in the past, they're still cheap by the standards of other musical instruments, so I wouldn't think of the price as a deal breaker, just something you might have to save a little longer to buy.